Barba vs Boyd

Re: RUMOUR?: Boyd released by Knights, here it comes

Maybe it's time to accept the inevitable? ... I'm going to support the Broncos no matter who puts on the jersey!
 
Re: RUMOUR?: Boyd released by Knights, here it comes

Won't be long now before the announcement is made
 
I am very neutral on this decision. I'm willing to give Boyd the benefit of the doubt, but if Barbas head rolls for this, I think it'll be a rubbish sequence of events.
 
Re: RUMOUR?: Boyd released by Knights, here it comes

austin71 said:
Maybe it's time to accept the inevitable? ... I'm going to support the Broncos no matter who puts on the jersey!
Click to expand...
I've accepted it long ago, and of course the Broncos stand above all of this, but like IBM says, it's gonna be a shitty sequence of events, because Boyd now has a mortgage on the FB position, no matter who else knocks or breaks the door down.

I just hope we don't loose one of Taylor or J. Nikorima, but I am pretty worried we will...
 
Re: RUMOUR?: Boyd released by Knights, here it comes

Porthoz said:
I've accepted it long ago, and of course the Broncos stand above all of this, but like IBM says, it's gonna be a shitty sequence of events, because Boyd now has a mortgage on the FB position, no matter who else knocks or breaks the door down.

I just hope we don't loose one of Taylor or J. Nikorima, but I am pretty worried we will...
Click to expand...
I think we would lose at least one of them regardless of Boyd coming
 
I'm completely prepared to get shot down here, but... it may not be the worst thing in the world having boyd at fullback when i think about the dynamics of our spine,

hunt mccullough and milford are all at their best running the ball, so i can see our outside backs not getting the ball enough, boyd to me is more of a norman esque type fullback, yes he is decently quick but i think his strengths lie in structured play roaming out the back for second man plays, which is bennents bread and butter... it might work out well having a more structured fullback rather then barba there leaving us with a spine full of livewires and no one to put the smart grubber into the in goal when needed or a simple cut out pass to a winger, yes i realise that hunts game is improving but it wouldnt be to bad to have an extra quality ballplayer out the back to ease the pressure off a new halves combination.

i also realise that barba isnt to bad of a ballplayer himself but alot of his passes look slow and easily interceptable. another player that needs to run first and pass second in my opinion

this is of course all speculation and it may not work out well at all but just some food for thought, very interested to see if anyone has a similar thought ?
 
Woah.. someone who actually has the same perspective as me, that's a nice change.

I can see Boyd putting in some nice little grubbers and cut out passes to Vidot & Copley, at a much more consistent rate than Barba did as well.
 
Said it a few times already and you all know I like repeating myself but I feel more confident in Boyd getting back to his 09/10 form than Barba getting back to his 2012 form.
 
Rabbir said:
Said it a few times already and you all know I like repeating myself but I feel more confident in Boyd getting back to his 09/10 form than Barba getting back to his 2012 form.
Click to expand...

The biggest problem for Boyd is that he knows the fullback position is his regardless of how he plays. He doesn't have that pressure to perform or perish that most players have, and just maybe that is a big part of why his performances have been mainly sub par (except origin).
 
Porthoz said:
I'm moving this to the appropriate thread.


What does Milford have to do with Barba vs. Boyd? The fact he has been confirmed as the 5/8 should only make things clearer.

These are the posts I am talking about, this one where you clearly indicate Boyd isn't that much of a fullback on the 22nd July 2014:


And another, where you specifically replied to my question whether we should get rid of Barba in favour of Boyd on the 4th August 2014:


As you can see, and you can check the original post, there is not mention of Milford anywhere. Barba's form did improve, and Boyd's... well, he didn't play much after that, between his stay at a clinic and subsequent holiday.
Click to expand...

Those posts were months ago. Posted when I was concerned about boyds form but since then the has been explanations for it. What can't you understand about that
 
Foordy said:
The biggest problem for Boyd is that he knows the fullback position is his regardless of how he plays. He doesn't have that pressure to perform or perish that most players have, and just maybe that is a big part of why his performances have been mainly sub par (except origin).
Click to expand...


It's key as to why Boyd is happy to come to Brisbane as well, because Bennett puts his emotional view before his professional in terms of Boyd. The kid can do no wrong in his eyes and alongside Bennett is his only guaranteed payday.
 
broncos4life said:
Those posts were months ago. Posted when I was concerned about boyds form but since then the has been explanations for it. What can't you understand about that
Click to expand...


And if that's how his personal life impact his playing ability, then I don't want him at the club.
 
broncos4life said:
Those posts were months ago. Posted when I was concerned about boyds form but since then the has been explanations for it. What can't you understand about that
Click to expand...

Accepting that Boyd's poor form at Newcastle his entire Knights stint is down to depression and that this fully explains it, it in no way alleviates it. We don't know if Boyd is mentally good right now and we certainly don't know if he's likely to lapse back into a bad state once again. Whilst you'd hope that it'll be good for Darius moving forward you can't turn a blind eye to it when building a roster and managing a cap.

There are risks to Boyd, in so many ways, that we just don't need to take.
 
New Posts

Unread

Watch

YouTube
0 1 1,227
1:25:31
NRL Round 12, 2002 - Wests Tigers vs Brisbane Broncos
View full media list »

Active Now

Total: 293 (members: 12, guests: 281)
Robots: 222
Back
Top