PLAYER Billy Walters

What role should Billy Walters play?

  • Total voters
    146
kman said:
Kevin Walters your a fucking joke there's no way in hell Billy Walters adds anything to this side and Billy wouldn't make it in the top 17 I'm any other club in the NRL. Seriously your dads the coach the only reason your playing in the NRL. He isn't even a dummyhalf his fucking Dad made him one just so he can see time in the NRL. **** Billy back off to the Q Cup where he belongs.
Click to expand...

Who should we play instead Kman.........?

this guy is already spoken for

1676354746617
 
Big Pete said:
Didn't Walters only last 10 minutes in his opening stint? Whereas Smoothy only came off for a small stint and had to back-up in the backrow?
Click to expand...
Yeah but we already know Walters can last longer. We barely saw Smoothy and when we did he was out on his feet. It was unfortunate but he was just simply a number on the field. He still has much to prove before he earns a top 17 spot and you know what, playing Q Cup for 11 rounds or whatever the rule is this year could be perfect for him.

Back end of the year could be

1 Walsh
6 Mam
7 Reynolds
9 Smoothy
14 Mozer

or it could be
1 Walsh
6 Mam
7 Reynolds
9 Walters
14 Paix

It really just depends on who steps up and right now the only player who does anything at hooker is Walters.
 
Cult said:
Yeah but we already know Walters can last longer. We barely saw Smoothy and when we did he was out on his feet. It was unfortunate but he was just simply a number on the field. He still has much to prove before he earns a top 17 spot and you know what, playing Q Cup for 11 rounds or whatever the rule is this year could be perfect for him.

Back end of the year could be

1 Walsh
6 Mam
7 Reynolds
9 Smoothy
14 Mozer

or it could be
1 Walsh
6 Mam
7 Reynolds
9 Walters
14 Paix

It really just depends on who steps up and right now the only player who does anything at hooker is Walters.
Click to expand...
I don't think it was a fair indication considering even Billy struggled even more despite the team having more possession during his stint. However I take your point that Smoothy didn't force his way into the 1st XIII on that performance. I also agree it's in his best interest to bide his time because the Broncos have the toughest opening two weeks of any team and he'd be on a hiding to nothing.
 
Great opportunity for Selwyn.

He could potentially be our starting fullback R1.
Feels like Reece is going to miss at least one game.
 
theshed said:
For what it’s worth, Denan Kemp has fairly strongly suggested Smoothy would be his first pick.
Click to expand...
Just listened to that. You have to hand it to the media for how much they can tiptoe around a steaming pile of elephant poo in the room without once mentioning the elephant.

If everyone in the media, from Fox down to old boys podcasts like Kemp, keeps saying the Broncos have a problem at hooker but act like there's a brick wall there stopping anything from happening, what kind of conversations are happening at Red Hill?

 
Billy was unbearable. Even when he was fresh on the field he threw it about 6 feet over Ahearn (???)'s head. or 6 feet behind Mam. It was gross, he was a total handbrake in attack. At least Paix threw it out in front of the halves.
 
Cult said:
Just out of curiosity, how much worth would you put in that opinion?

Also the biggest takeaway from this game was Smoothy was out on his feet after less than half a game. What exactly do you guys think is going to happen when he plays against a first grade team without quarters?
Click to expand...
How much weight would I put on the opinion of a guy who’s played the game professionally, in the team being spoken about, and has made a small media empire based on sharing his opinion of the sport multiple times a week for the last few years?

It’s not gospel but it’s worth a hell of a lot more than most on here.

Not sure I saw Smoothy “out on his feet” but I’ll happily rewatch his stint
 
Big Del said:
WTF is up with Billy running from dummy half making a half break but never linking up ?
Frustrates the shit outa me . Every game he beats the markers then dies with the ball .

I really hoped the #1 or #13 would practice following him when he runs . But apparently not .
Click to expand...
He isn’t fast enough to make an actual break and he isn’t skilled enough to link up with anyone. Plus he does it at poor times so most of the team are setting up for a planned play which Billy kills by running it. Usually on the 4th so someone else has to do his job for him and pass it to the kicker
 
theshed said:
He isn’t fast enough to make an actual break and he isn’t skilled enough to link up with anyone. Plus he does it at poor times so most of the team are setting up for a planned play which Billy kills by running it. Usually on the 4th so someone else has to do his job for him and pass it to the kicker
Click to expand...

I'm surprised (considering your recent turn of leaf) that you've missed the point, Big D was trying to make.

Nobody is there for him to pass it to, when he does decide to run. Do you think CSmith gave everyone a great big nod when he decided to run.......the players in the ruck have to be aware. Your fullback should be hovering around the ruck until late in the tackle count.....your no.13 similar. Soley waiting on a dummy half run chance.....
 
Mr Fourex said:
I'm surprised (considering your recent turn of leaf) that you've missed the point, Big D was trying to make.

Nobody is there for him to pass it to, when he does decide to run. Do you think CSmith gave everyone a great big nod when he decided to run.......the players in the ruck have to be aware. Your fullback should be hovering around the ruck until late in the tackle count.....your no.13 similar. Soley waiting on a dummy half run chance.....
Click to expand...
They are also valid points but the fullback won’t be ready to link up with the hooker if it’s the 4th tackle and the halfback is calling a play
 
New Posts

Unread

Watch

YouTube
0 0 733
1:29:58
NSWRL Minor Semi Final, 1990 - Brisbane Broncos vs Manly Sea Eagles
View full media list »

Active Now

  • Battler
Total: 106 (members: 1, guests: 105)
Robots: 284
Top
  AdBlock Message
Please consider adding BHQ to your Adblock Whitelist. We do our best to make sure it doesn't affect your experience on the website, and the funds help us pay server and software costs.