Jack Bird has been infinitely better than last year even though he was carrying that sternum injury last season.Every single player in the side has gone backward under his tenure.
Jake Turpin has actually raised his stock 10 fold this season. Same can be said about Payne Haas.
Ofahengaue, Haas and Fifita broke into the Origin arena this year under his tenure. Lodge was also on the cusp for NSW.
The only players I would say you could argue have gone backwards under Seibold are Boyd, McCullough, Isaako and TPJ.
Could make a case for Milford but he has always been rocks and diamonds and is probably playing at the same level as last season.
TPJ at least played his career best game under Seibold.
Isaako has a pretty bad family illness which might explain why his head has not been in the game lately so I’ll cut him a bit of slack.
Boyd and Macca are aging and peaked years ago so their decline under Seibold is no surprise as it was already heading that way alarmingly under Bennett.
I agree Seibold deserves some criticism for some of the lack of success for issues within his control but let’s not throw agenda driven tripe at him about everyone going backwards under him when it is so far from actual fact that it is borderline trolling.