Shane Tronc
QCup Player
- Apr 7, 2018
- 384
- 1,220
Given how entitled some broncos fans are, I don’t blame them for revelling in us sucking
Broncos Player Movement and Rumours 2020
- Thread starter BrentTatesChin
- Start date
- Status
- Oct 7, 2017
- 3,722
- 4,854
Easy fix using kpi's. If you develop your own players yout salary cap is increased accordingly to accomodate those you wish to keep.
On the flip side if you don't develop and make a habit of plundering those who do your cap is reduced accordingly. Sure to balance the ledger in regard Roosters and Storm etc and even things up which is the purpose of said cap anyway.
- Sep 6, 2013
- 56,893
- 69,503
Aren't you basically contradicting yourself here. You are saying that if they are at a club by 19, they are developed by the GF side but in the case of Brisbane, these 7 Gold Coast kids were all at Brisbane before 19 (I believe), except for Teo who came in from the Tigers from memory as an already established player. Wouldn't it be fair to say that players are usually showing what they are like by the time they are 19?
Take Sam Walker as an example, he was THE gun playmaker coming through and was in hot demand, Roosters come in with more money than anyone else and take him out of another system. Isn't that the definition of poaching?
Unless you are saying players only start developing at 18/19?
For mine, my dislike for the Titans is based on the incessant carry-on, fanfare and circle-jerk that follows their still very sporadic wins over us and anytime they “get one over the Broncos and sign boom *insert name here*”.
They should be cautious not to get too far ahead of themselves. Sans 2013 and 2016, this is their best season since 2010 but context is important, they are 12th.
Prior to this year, 12th would be considered a catastrophic failure for the Broncos.
When the Titans are beating the Broncos regularly and comfortably (be careful what you wish for I suppose
) and winning premierships, that’s when they'll have something to crow about.Until then, fact remains they are 14 seasons in with 2 wooden spoons, only made finals in 3 seasons and have won no trophies. By that stage we’d won 5 premierships and after 33 seasons, still no spoons (don’t make a liar out of me Dogs).
Last edited:
I haven't said the Broncos didn't developed Coates they've put work into him, but when people bag other clubs for having players from other areas it makes no sense to me when the Broncos have seven players from the Coast.
People have different views of 'junior' some people have the old school, he was born in Redfern lives across the road from Redfern Oval view and others have the who cares where you come from if you were at the Broncos by 18 you're a 'Broncos Junior." I think the where you were born approach is dead, you can't limit yourself like that. If the kid is at the Coast and you can get him to Brisbane then good luck to you but I don't think people apply it evenly and it doesn't mean he didn't come from the Coast.
It seems to be a lot of picking and choosing and switching between the two depending on what club you want to talk about.
If Sam goes on to be a 200 game Rooster, the only people that can take credit are the Jets and Roosters. They signed him in grade 12 what more could the Roosters do? Sam was 16 or might have just turned 17- how much younger could he sign his first NRL contract?
Roosters offer wasn't the biggest it was just the best. Roosters were the only club interested until Ikin mentioned him on 360 in June and everyone started to care and then it was too late and half hearted.
- May 21, 2013
- 19,708
- 20,983
Put a cork in the Papalii idea
Any player that gets up and sent off with ball in hand isn't the kind of player we need at the club right now. We need players that respect the jersey and will put all in to put back pride into it.
Not disputing it at all , would much rather spend the money on development.
And it's how it goes with clubs poaching, of course clubs are going to chase the good kids. Would be nice for a little more incentive to keep them though, can't keep them all but I'm sure more can be done by the nrl.
The one thing that I will disagree with is Fifita, definitely a Brisbane jr was born here.
There's some good footy schools to choose from and Keebra is definitely one of those, of course your going to choose the right one.
I bleed Maroon
International Rep
- Apr 17, 2013
- 15,982
- 20,921
Of course. Why would a player of his calibre come up here to kill his own career? The shine is well and truly off the club from a signings perspective, and it will be a long road to getting it back, if ever. We will have to pay massive overs on a regular basis which is why we need to be extremely careful with who we target (oh god.)
- Sep 6, 2013
- 56,893
- 69,503
Well said. I think you have touched on a separate issue in terms of the Broncos. For all the 'gun' young players that Nolan seems to have bought in, Brisbane still tend to miss out on the very best ones a lot.
- Sep 28, 2012
- 13,220
- 11,417
Yeah I’m sorry but if a kid is born in Brisbane, played junior footy for a Brisbane club, and/or was scouted by Brisbane, and then moved to Keebra or PBC, that does not make them a Gold Coast anything.
Dearden for example is a Toowoomba and Mackay junior, then Brisbane, before anything Gold Coast.
It’s only because they have good footy schools.
Anywhere can have them (begs the question why there aren’t more/better ones in Brisbane)
Dearden for example is a Toowoomba and Mackay junior, then Brisbane, before anything Gold Coast.
It’s only because they have good footy schools.
Anywhere can have them (begs the question why there aren’t more/better ones in Brisbane)
Last edited:
- Mar 4, 2008
- 35,067
- 41,913
BTW, Roosters resigning the Worlds bets player for 6 mil over 5 years....highway robbery.....how did they do that i wonder..?
I hate the Roosters creative accounting as much as the next bloke ... but $6 million over 5 years is $1.2 million per year. that puts him around the highest paid player in the game.
of course, when he comes of contract the Rorters will probably claim to have $2 million free a year
Dearden played MM for Tweed and played for Currumbin Eagles. I know he's from Mackay but that's not where the Broncos got him from when they signed him. He was playing on the Coast, for two Coast teams and going to school on the Coast- that's pretty Coastie.
He never played football in Toowoomba he was just born there.
I assume the problem there is that Brisbane's big school are GPS schools and play rugby.
Last edited:
- May 21, 2013
- 19,708
- 20,983
I've got a bit of a left field idea for a short-term Fullback option, if you guys would like to entertain the idea.. Matt Moylan.
Now, before you completely shit on the idea.. I'm well aware that he's made of glass and hasn't been healthy in years. He's also incredibly overpaid. This idea comes from a few viewpoints:
One, I assume the Sharks would be more than happy to pay at least 50% of his salary to get him off their books, so he'd be coming at a reasonable price.
Two, his contract expires after 2021, so he'd be coming on a 1-year rental to see how he goes.
Three, he's an experienced player that was a proven clutch performer before he was betrayed by his hamstrings.
Four, he's still one of the best ball players in the competition, and his short kicking game has actually taken some steps forward in recent years with his time spent at Five-Eighth.
Five, we've proven in the last 24 months that we know how to deal with chronic hamstring issues. Tevita Pangai Jr was hindered with them a couple of years ago, we sent him off to work with an expert physiotherapist to strengthen his hamstring and the supporting muscles / tendons, he hasn't had an issue since.
Six, his last healthy season was in 2018 with the Sharks, he was extremely good that year. He finished that season with 13 forced drop outs & 16 try assists playing almost exclusively at Five-Eighth, which I don't believe is his best position.
Seven, he just turned 29 - If we can solve, or at least improve his soft tissue dramas over the off-season, there is still some upside that we could get a few more high quality years out of him.
Eight, why not? It's not like there's any phenomenal off-contract players that are joining the club in 2021, we may as well use the cap space we have on a couple of flyers with short-term upside like Moylan, Foran, etc.
Now, before you completely shit on the idea.. I'm well aware that he's made of glass and hasn't been healthy in years. He's also incredibly overpaid. This idea comes from a few viewpoints:
One, I assume the Sharks would be more than happy to pay at least 50% of his salary to get him off their books, so he'd be coming at a reasonable price.
Two, his contract expires after 2021, so he'd be coming on a 1-year rental to see how he goes.
Three, he's an experienced player that was a proven clutch performer before he was betrayed by his hamstrings.
Four, he's still one of the best ball players in the competition, and his short kicking game has actually taken some steps forward in recent years with his time spent at Five-Eighth.
Five, we've proven in the last 24 months that we know how to deal with chronic hamstring issues. Tevita Pangai Jr was hindered with them a couple of years ago, we sent him off to work with an expert physiotherapist to strengthen his hamstring and the supporting muscles / tendons, he hasn't had an issue since.
Six, his last healthy season was in 2018 with the Sharks, he was extremely good that year. He finished that season with 13 forced drop outs & 16 try assists playing almost exclusively at Five-Eighth, which I don't believe is his best position.
Seven, he just turned 29 - If we can solve, or at least improve his soft tissue dramas over the off-season, there is still some upside that we could get a few more high quality years out of him.
Eight, why not? It's not like there's any phenomenal off-contract players that are joining the club in 2021, we may as well use the cap space we have on a couple of flyers with short-term upside like Moylan, Foran, etc.
Financeguy
NRL Player
- Apr 24, 2013
- 2,093
- 3,323
Its not the craziest idea that's been posted on here and you are right that the Sharks would probably be interested in off loading him but my big concern around Moylan is his attitude. From all reports he had a poor attitude in his last year(s) at the Panthers and i've also heard he is a bit of a "take the easy option" guy at the Sharks.
I'm not sure we can cope with another bad attitude in the squad from a so called 'experience leader'. I'd rather have guys who will play busted and scrap for every loose ball with less talent than a guy who will willingly sit out another week of footy if he gets the note from his doctor.
ozzball
QCup Player
- Mar 17, 2013
- 321
- 683
Some mutterings about Benji coming back to Red Hill ???
www.sportingnews.com
Broncos open to Benji Marshall return – but ask unwanted Tigers star to wait until they have a coach | Sporting News Australia
Unwanted Tigers veteran Benji Marshall has fielded an expression of interest from the Broncos about a possible return to Red Hill next season.
www.sportingnews.com
Last edited:
- Status
