Agreed.
He'd be the final piece in the puzzle at 9. But realistically, we wouldn't want to carry him beyond this season with Mozer and Smoothy coming through. And obviously, given Billy will have mandatory dibs on 14 neither will end up getting a fair go.
If he wants to play in the halves beyond this season - which is almost certainly the case - we just plain don't need him, and absolutely not on the money he'd expect. If he were younger we might consider him as successor to Reynolds, but the pair are likely to retire around the same time. Plus, I actually think Reynolds is the better half. We'd be better off extending Reynolds at least another year.
And while we're reshuffling hookers/halves, this would be a good opportunity to relocate Paix and Madden. Both are good enough to hold down a starting position, and bloom, at another club. Just not us.