Brocko
State of Origin Rep
Contributor
- Feb 23, 2014
- 5,145
- 7,526
- Thread starter
- #1,891
If United sign Semedo they deserve a terrible season.Please sign Semedo. Thanks.
If United sign Semedo they deserve a terrible season.Please sign Semedo. Thanks.
If United sign Semedo they deserve a terrible season.
How much do you want for Kilman?We need the money, i hope they do
How much do you want for Kilman?
LFC should be all over that tbhI'd have been happy with the 30 million Napoli offered. If he got a bit of mongrel about him i think he would go up levels. He's way too laid back.
LFC should be all over that tbh
Left footed CB is exactly what they need to cover VVD and being a home grown player would be a bonus
He's not worth that but I'd almost pay it if I was LFC. Home grown problem is a huge issue and he's about the right age tooWe wanted 35 million and Napoli wouldnt go that high. He's got a lot of potential, and at 26 he is coming into his prime years. I still think he is just a little too quiet still.
Weird thing with him is he was picked to play for Ukraine and was keen to do so as his parents are Ukrainian, but because he played Futsal for England he is ineligible as Futsal is covered under Fifa rules bizarrely.
He's not worth that but I'd almost pay it if I was LFC. Home grown problem is a huge issue and he's about the right age too
I rate White as a much better defender than Kilman. Keane is one of the worst CBs in the league.I think 35 million is probably a little light tbh for a left footed English center half if he is moving to an English club. They arent that common. Not going to compare his transfer somebody like Maguire because that was a ridiculous fee, but Ben White got a big move after 1 good year in the premier league for a lot more than 35 million and Kilman has been good now for over 2 seasons. You look at players like Keane as well who went for 30 million i think if we wanted we could ask for an inflated fee. Knowing us, we wont even though players like Kilman are sold at a premium. We never exploit the English tax.
I rate White as a much better defender than Kilman. Keane is one of the worst CBs in the league.
Colwill is by far the best of the bunch and LFC were very keen, the $50mil rumoured was a snip for him.
Now that Konate is injured LFC will definitely have to do something back there. Hincapie from Leverkusen is strongly linked at the moment but will take $40-50mil to get.
I don't know about that. White was brilliant at Brighton and one of the best CB's in the competition in 2020/21. The same logic could apply in terms of going under the radar because he wasn't at a top side then (Brighton were 16th). I think his versatility is a major factor in why he's rated so highly too, he was on the shortlist for best RB in the league last season and he can cover the entire backline.White isnt any better than Kilman. Max goes under the radar because he isnt playing for a top side every week. You cant blame teams for not buying English players though if they can help it. They are very overpriced.
Colwill we will see. He's done nothing yet. He got bullied all game by Antonio the other day ( wasnt the only one tbf to him ) and the West Ham fans think he is on his last legs. That kind of fee is everything wrong with football if an established, proven premier league player can be valued less than a kid who has played less than 20 top flight games. Loads of promising young players fade away after bright starts ( Chelsea have had plenty of them as well, i remember the hype around Loftus-Cheek and Hudson-Odoi ). Only a an idiotic, desperate team would be paying that.