rnabokov
State of Origin Captain
Contributor
- Mar 5, 2008
- 9,586
- 8,889
Jeba said:Kemp would wanna be a good boot if he is landing goals from Langlands Park.
rna, I just don't understand where the panic comes from. We have already locked Gillett up for the next 3 years, we aren't going to lose him. And also, playing off the bench doesn't mean you're not as good as the others. In fact, impact from the bench is extremely important in the modern game. Gillett provides much better impact than Parker, and whilst he could do just as well as Parker in the starting 13, the fact is Parker does a damn good job doing what he does and we gain a lot more with him at lock and Gillett on the bench.
Same sort of formula as we had in 2006 - the bench utility (McGuire, now Glenn), the bench back rower (Parker, now Gillett), and 2 front rowers (Hannant and Carlaw).
And yes before you point out the obvious, yes Parker was on the bench back then, but these days he is not the sort of player to provide impact from the bench. He is best served on the field for the entire 80 minutes.
Whether that be at lock or not, is certainly debatable. But he has certainly earned a starting spot.
Jeb, I'm not panicking. My analogy is that playing Gillett from the bench next year is to me the same logic as playing Inglis off the bench.
IMO, Gillett from lock will provide our team with the same 80 minute impact as Inglis in the centres. .
IMO, we have lost a lot since Tunza left. We have a ready-made replacement for him in Gillett.
Why keep a rising superstar who can contribute brilliance for 80 minutes on the bench?
Did Brad Clyde play from the bench? My memory of Clyde - the best lock in the game bar none, was in Canberra's top side at 18, and yes, I am comparing Gillett to Clyde - so far at least.
Of course Matt has to prove himself, but playing him at centre, 5/8, 2nd row - anywhere but his best position, is fron=m now on, plain stupid IMO.
If we want real impact, then play T'eo off the bench.
I'm not worries about losing Gillett. It's Glenn I'm worried about losing.
Corey is a very good player, but not in the same league as T'eo, Thaiday, or Gillett.
As I see it, we keep either Parker or Glenn - not both.