Kaz
State of Origin Captain
- Mar 5, 2008
- 10,054
- 3,817
- Status
john1420
It's Bronco Time
Contributor
- Aug 27, 2008
- 2,810
- 3,973
I am not at all convinced by DCE
I don't understand how people want to bring in guys like DCE who have had 1 good season
Sure, maybe DCE will be a super star, but we give that label away far too quickly
There is no way he deserves to be in the starting line up ahead of Cronk who has done his apprenticeship
And he doesn't belong on the bench in front of others who are either more experienced or more versatile (usually both)
I don't understand how people want to bring in guys like DCE who have had 1 good season
Sure, maybe DCE will be a super star, but we give that label away far too quickly
There is no way he deserves to be in the starting line up ahead of Cronk who has done his apprenticeship
And he doesn't belong on the bench in front of others who are either more experienced or more versatile (usually both)
jarro65
State of Origin Rep
- Jun 26, 2008
- 7,187
- 3,215
ethos
NRL Player
- Mar 4, 2008
- 1,661
- 138
Speculation on the FoxSports site that the side will be:
Billy Slater, Darius Boyd, Greg Inglis, Justin Hodges, Brent Tate, Johnathan Thurston, Cooper Cronk, Matt Scott, Cameron Smith (c), Petero Civoniceva, Sam Thaiday, Nate Myles, Ashley Harrison. Interchange: Matt Gillett, Ben Hannant, Dave Shillington, Dave Taylor. 18th man: Daly Cherry-Evans.
I can live with that for sure but after seeing NSW's side, I fear we may be a bit too heavy and cumbersome up front. Would be a tough decision but I'd leave out Civ, start with Hannant and bring in either Parker or McGuire on the bench. I think Petero may get shown up by speed and footwork in the ruck which would place greater pressure on those around him.
But that's the only slight concern I can find, that pack should devour NSW.
Billy Slater, Darius Boyd, Greg Inglis, Justin Hodges, Brent Tate, Johnathan Thurston, Cooper Cronk, Matt Scott, Cameron Smith (c), Petero Civoniceva, Sam Thaiday, Nate Myles, Ashley Harrison. Interchange: Matt Gillett, Ben Hannant, Dave Shillington, Dave Taylor. 18th man: Daly Cherry-Evans.
I can live with that for sure but after seeing NSW's side, I fear we may be a bit too heavy and cumbersome up front. Would be a tough decision but I'd leave out Civ, start with Hannant and bring in either Parker or McGuire on the bench. I think Petero may get shown up by speed and footwork in the ruck which would place greater pressure on those around him.
But that's the only slight concern I can find, that pack should devour NSW.
Browny
State of Origin Captain
- Apr 9, 2008
- 11,993
- 7,191
Give GI and hodgo good early ball and watch the magic
Bucking Beads
International Captain
- Mar 5, 2008
- 24,429
- 7,731
They won't leave out Petro IMO. He will grow a leg in origin I reckon, he always has.
Big Pete
International Captain
- Mar 12, 2008
- 32,132
- 25,803
Happy with that side.
Petero is the best prop in Origin history & I don't think he's getting a fair go at the Broncs this season. Still, doesn't stop him from making good runs right up the middle and earning our side the roll onto score points.
He's finally starting to show his age, but he'll be right for Origin.
Tate's interesting. 3 serious knee injuries, really wasn't great on the wing 2 serious knee injuries ago...it's a concern but who else do we have? Rather him than say Graham and what a story it is for Brent after the 2010 4Ns. He's really put his hand up these past two weeks and I wouldn't have that big a problem.
Let's make it 7!
Petero is the best prop in Origin history & I don't think he's getting a fair go at the Broncs this season. Still, doesn't stop him from making good runs right up the middle and earning our side the roll onto score points.
He's finally starting to show his age, but he'll be right for Origin.
Tate's interesting. 3 serious knee injuries, really wasn't great on the wing 2 serious knee injuries ago...it's a concern but who else do we have? Rather him than say Graham and what a story it is for Brent after the 2010 4Ns. He's really put his hand up these past two weeks and I wouldn't have that big a problem.
Let's make it 7!
Bucking Beads
International Captain
- Mar 5, 2008
- 24,429
- 7,731
Big Pete
International Captain
- Mar 12, 2008
- 32,132
- 25,803
He's not getting the game time he deserves.
21 mins. this week, 34 last - he's a better player than that and when he's been given the right amount of game time he's delivered his best performances.
Guy should be playing 40-50 each week, no question and I reckon Mal won't hesitate and Qld will benefit.
Brisbane will too come finals.
21 mins. this week, 34 last - he's a better player than that and when he's been given the right amount of game time he's delivered his best performances.
Guy should be playing 40-50 each week, no question and I reckon Mal won't hesitate and Qld will benefit.
Brisbane will too come finals.
Bucking Beads
International Captain
- Mar 5, 2008
- 24,429
- 7,731
So which prop out of McGuire and Hannant do you take minutes off??
Big Pete
International Captain
- Mar 12, 2008
- 32,132
- 25,803
Both could do with 10 less minutes (which would be 50 mins based on this week), but of course it's a case by case scenario. If Thaiday wasn't captain I'd suggest he should hit the pine, he isn't putting in enough at this stage because of his rib injury.
Sometimes having an awesome pack can have it's disadvantages.
Sometimes having an awesome pack can have it's disadvantages.
Bucking Beads
International Captain
- Mar 5, 2008
- 24,429
- 7,731
Don't agree, I think we are a better side with McGuire and Hannant on the park so the longer they are on the field the better.
Like giving the oldest prop in the side less minutes.
Like giving the oldest prop in the side less minutes.
Last edited:
Big Pete
International Captain
- Mar 12, 2008
- 32,132
- 25,803
You mean the greatest prop of all time.
Bucking Beads
International Captain
- Mar 5, 2008
- 24,429
- 7,731
Doesn't take away from the fact that he is 36 and on the way out. Still he generally plays 30-40 mins which is enough IMO. He may get more as the season progresses who knows.
Bucking Beads
International Captain
- Mar 5, 2008
- 24,429
- 7,731
He is playing well but not as well as McGuire and Hannant.
Big Pete
International Captain
- Mar 12, 2008
- 32,132
- 25,803
Civo will just have to prove you wrong in Origin Beads.
He's got plenty of experience, been doing it for 30 games now.
He's got plenty of experience, been doing it for 30 games now.
Bucking Beads
International Captain
- Mar 5, 2008
- 24,429
- 7,731
In what way will he be proving me wrong???
Big Pete
International Captain
- Mar 12, 2008
- 32,132
- 25,803
By playing awesome despite being 'on the way out'.
- Status
