Adam Reynolds is so overrated, it's not funny. He has nothing other than his kicking game, which admittedly is terrific...
It will be a good tough test, but they're not the boogeyman some people think they are, especially without Sam Burgess.
Great postIt's been a while since I posted over here, have to more often ( I'm Kiwi over at The Front Row forums ).
I'm looking forward to round 1, yes Souths looked impressive against St Helens, but I think we have the right players to trouble and beat them. Plus lets be honest Souths looked no better in the WCC than the Roosters did last year who didn't exactly set the NRL on fire till mid season. But that aside and not counting on that happening we are still in with a chance.
With Hunt and Milford we can play both sides of the ruck now, and both players are strong on both sides, which is a bonus, Glenn and Thaiday look like they are where they belong, out wide and running hard. Up the middle despite having the smaller pack we have the aggression to match it with the bigger packs, Wigan tried to bash us out of the game and we just kept coming at them and won up the middle easily.
I only have one concern going into round 1, will or attack come together or will it take a few rounds to gel. I'm certainly not going to panic if it doesn't gel and we lose the game, because it will gel and when that happens we will show that we can now attack from anywhere, hopefully from round 1, but I'll take it in a few rounds or even half a dozen rounds, because when it happens all teams will fear us.
My team for round 1 would be
1 - Kahu
2 - Oates
3 - Copely
4 - Hodges
5 - Vidot
6 - Milford
7 - Hunt
8 - McGuire
9 - McCullough
10 - Blair
11 - Glenn
12 - Thaiday
13 - Parker
14 - Nikorima
15 - Gavet
16 - Gillett
17 - Joe O
Unfortunately I think Bennett will run with Dodds and Miranta over Joe O and Oates. Also I would like to see Nikorima come on in the last 15 minutes of the game, not to replace McCullough but to be given a license to thrill, to just do his thing and play whatever is in front of him, because while he filled in for McCullough well enough and will do against Souths, with a free run in the final 15 he could really catch some of the bigger Souths players out and put the hurt on. But in saying all that I wanted Bennett back so whatever he runs out there I will show faith in and not lay the boot in.
Macca should be taking every long kick.
Nope that becomes readable and makes it easier to charge down if the markers know he is always kicking long, even.if he drops out of dummy half for it he will always be pressured. He needs to look at kicking more from dummy half he just needs to pick when.
Hunts pretty bloody readable and isn't anywhere near as good as Macca in that regard. Maybe not all long kicks but he certainly needs to do more.
It's been a while since I posted over here, have to more often ( I'm Kiwi over at The Front Row forums ).
I'm looking forward to round 1, yes Souths looked impressive against St Helens, but I think we have the right players to trouble and beat them. Plus lets be honest Souths looked no better in the WCC than the Roosters did last year who didn't exactly set the NRL on fire till mid season. But that aside and not counting on that happening we are still in with a chance.
With Hunt and Milford we can play both sides of the ruck now, and both players are strong on both sides, which is a bonus, Glenn and Thaiday look like they are where they belong, out wide and running hard. Up the middle despite having the smaller pack we have the aggression to match it with the bigger packs, Wigan tried to bash us out of the game and we just kept coming at them and won up the middle easily.
I only have one concern going into round 1, will or attack come together or will it take a few rounds to gel. I'm certainly not going to panic if it doesn't gel and we lose the game, because it will gel and when that happens we will show that we can now attack from anywhere, hopefully from round 1, but I'll take it in a few rounds or even half a dozen rounds, because when it happens all teams will fear us.
My team for round 1 would be
1 - Kahu
2 - Oates
3 - Copely
4 - Hodges
5 - Vidot
6 - Milford
7 - Hunt
8 - McGuire
9 - McCullough
10 - Blair
11 - Glenn
12 - Thaiday
13 - Parker
14 - Nikorima
15 - Gavet
16 - Gillett
17 - Joe O
Unfortunately I think Bennett will run with Dodds and Miranta over Joe O and Oates. Also I would like to see Nikorima come on in the last 15 minutes of the game, not to replace McCullough but to be given a license to thrill, to just do his thing and play whatever is in front of him, because while he filled in for McCullough well enough and will do against Souths, with a free run in the final 15 he could really catch some of the bigger Souths players out and put the hurt on. But in saying all that I wanted Bennett back so whatever he runs out there I will show faith in and not lay the boot in.
Reynolds always has had a top kicking game, probably the best in the NRL alongside Thurston and Cronk. And he is an excellent goal kicker too... but that is where it ends. The rest of his game is average at best imo.I'm not sure about your comments about Reynolds, P. Looks to me like he has more or less re-invented himself and he played a lot better v St H than I can remember in a long while. On top of that, he adds a lot of value with his goal kicking.
I always feel the same way about Sutton, and Stewart. They are not to be under-estimated. The whole Souths side looked well oiled and and had good speed and momentum in the game v St H.
And this quote from Maguire sums it up well - for me one critical element of a seriously dangerous side:
"I think with Greg, allowing him to swing round to both sides with two ball-playing back-rowers adds a big difference to us.
"It frees up our halves.
Recast Rabbitohs pose different threat - NRL.com
This is going to be one hell of a wake up call for us, and our new coach.
Oates on the wing?
What a great idea. Now why didn't I think of that.
Reynolds always has had a top kicking game, probably the best in the NRL alongside Thurston and Cronk. And he is an excellent goal kicker too... but that is where it ends. The rest of his game is average at best imo.
Against St Helens, as many people have said, he had time to sip a cappuccino before taking a kick on each of the final tackles. Compare that to the pressure Wigan put on Hunt... there is a world, a galaxy even, of difference!
Of course souffs is a good team, and a very tough adversary to start with, but they're far from unbeatable and I doubt they will be better this season with Glenn Stewart and BP's love child Chris Grevsmuhl, than they were last year with Sam Burger and Ben Te'o. :wink:
Milford and Kahu are better kickers than Barba and Hoffman respectively, so that should make a difference. Macca needs to take a more active role as well, like Smith does at the Storm.