LIVE Round 16 Discussion

Discussion in 'NRL Live Game Chat' started by Super Freak, Jun 26, 2018.

    Nah Granville didn’t go looking for burgess, sure he wrapped his arms, but what was he supposed to do step aside? The onus is on burgess to run a clean decoy line, not on the defender to avoid contact. Reynolds took the ball directly behind burgess who effectively ran as a lead blocker. Bad call for mine.
     
    2ndPhase likes this.
  1. Sproj

    Sproj

    13,521
    6,253
    Yep it was the wrong call simply because it has been a no try for the last couple of seasons. Granville clearly gave up thinking he'd get the penalty but that isn't the point.
     
  2. Smartseal

    Smartseal QCup Player

    292
    116
    It's my opinion that the so called early year blitz by referees has affected their judgement and decision making, & the flunker doesn't help
     
    Sproj likes this.
  3. Sproj

    Sproj

    13,521
    6,253
    Man, JT really has gone too long. Still has some magic clearly but so few and far between now.
     
  4. Sproj

    Sproj

    13,521
    6,253
    The Cows just look so old and slow.
     
  5. I bleed Maroon

    I bleed Maroon State of Origin Rep

    6,377
    3,650
    That moment when Sam Burgess puts in a better kick than Nikorima ever has
     
  6. Sproj

    Sproj

    13,521
    6,253
    Goodness me, Cows pull another flukey try.
     
  7. Sproj

    Sproj

    13,521
    6,253
    Turn it up. KNik almost got Roberts a try this very week with a kick. He isn't going great a halfback sure, but he isn't as completely bad as a lot of people make out and the Broncs are still winning.
     
  8. Sproj

    Sproj

    13,521
    6,253
    Feldt has had a shocker.
     
  9. Tom

    Tom NRL Captain

    4,582
    3,328
    He is better than Oates apparently.
     
  10. ningnangnong

    ningnangnong HACK THE PLANET!!!

    22,893
    6,462
    Reynolds lands it.
     
  11. Onya Reynolds.
     
  12. Horseheadsup

    Horseheadsup NRL Player

    1,863
    779
    Cows get chance
     
  13. Sproj

    Sproj

    13,521
    6,253
    Inglis looks like he has broken a thumb.
     
  14. Broncs_Fan

    Broncs_Fan NRL Player

    2,104
    814
    Nik isn't going to take us to a Premiership at halfback though. Shane Perry had Lockyer and Milford is not Lockyer.
     
  15. Broncs_Fan

    Broncs_Fan NRL Player

    2,104
    814
    It wasn't a defensive decision though. Granville put his arms up to brace from being obliterated by a massive man. It was a clear obstruction.
     
  16. Granville doesn't complain, at least not that I saw. That's an important factor, as players that are obstructed complain.

    He looks at Cook, and then he sees Burgess. He plants his feet, he leans forward to get the shoulder into the tackle which is what you do when making a tackle and he wraps the arms around. He wasn't putting the arms up to brace for the contact, he wraps them around the player. That's making a defensive decision. Mal said it best, he committed to the tackle. He made no attempt to follow the ball despite having the opportunity to do so. And the ball was received well on the outside shoulder.

    It was an excellent piece of work from Cook to hold the pass and fake to go short to Burgess. That attracted Granville's attention.

    It's a try. What Granville did is initiating contact.
     
  17. Sproj

    Sproj

    13,521
    6,253
    All of this is true...except that has been an obstruction for probably the last 18 months or more. It was well worked but regardless, Burgess got in the way and Reynolds took advantage of the hole formed, as mentioned by another poster, Burgess is the definition of a lead runner or blocker or shepherd, whatever you prefer, in that instance.

    That sort of situation has been called back multiple times in the last season or so.
     
  18. Morkel

    Morkel

    19,104
    15,185
    If Granville does nothing and just gets bowled over, it'd be a penalty for sure. It's sad that you have to milk it just to get the right decision.

    But the Rabbitohs were dudded anyway. Two really bad knock-on calls that never were, and that disallowed try. The replay clearly showed that the ball went backwards off the hand, before hitting his head, and then the bunker say "the ball goes forward off his hand". Absolute **** joke.
     
    Last edited: Jul 1, 2018
    Sproj likes this.

Share This Page

Loading...