Finbar
QCup Player
- May 21, 2018
- 823
- 2,120
Nobody around on a few of Billy's runs as well. One in particular down the left side and not a second rower, centre or fullback within cooee, despite him staying alive and keeping his hands free.
POST GAME [Round 19, 2024] Broncos vs Dragons
- Thread starter ningnangnong
- Start date
_wwong
International Captain
- May 27, 2013
- 23,670
- 22,502
It seems like our game is to have the fullback out wide every set. Our breaks or offloads up the middle have no speed players around at all.
_wwong
International Captain
- May 27, 2013
- 23,670
- 22,502
That was mam. Now he’s just the link man to get the ball to walsh.
bert_lifts
QCup Player
- May 15, 2021
- 514
- 1,175
I really hope they have back flipped on Marty. If they aren't I'll lose the little amount of respect for kev I have left. Some of his runs were immense and the intensity generated hype. You could feel it in the crowd. The fact plodders like baker were ahead of him is criminal
Walters Snr’s praise for Walters Jr made me want to barf. It was heavily obvious once he went off the field the energy shifted and they were able to create plays. He will continue to play him till the end of time. I despise when father and son are together in a club for this reason, because he’ll never drop his son no matter how horrible he is.
Bucking Beads
International Captain
- Mar 5, 2008
- 24,546
- 7,827
It’s not a choice. One has a contract and the other doesn’tCan you imagine choosing to keep Baker over him???!
But they’re choosing to not keep Marty which is crazy considering his replacement is BAKER!! BAKERRRRRRR!
Cavalo
NYC Player
- Sep 20, 2019
- 209
- 477
This was pointed out in other threads and earlier but where is the next gen of forwards and outside backs? Willison and Piakura debuted in 2022, Mariner last year. Karapani came from Souths.
We've seen Te Kura...
I know Roosters, Storm and Dolphins have been active with signing SEQ juniors but we can't even find a QCup sleeper? Are we even checking out the bush, Wide Bay, Rocky, Mackay?
It was also obvious last night they we would be a big man short - a QCup player with 50+ games and a hard work ethic to do a few hard runs and tackles to go with Marty would have made a difference, especially as Jensen and Willison do not have big motors (X is improving). Playing Smoothy at lock was a poor decision although he gave it a crack.
We've seen Te Kura...
I know Roosters, Storm and Dolphins have been active with signing SEQ juniors but we can't even find a QCup sleeper? Are we even checking out the bush, Wide Bay, Rocky, Mackay?
It was also obvious last night they we would be a big man short - a QCup player with 50+ games and a hard work ethic to do a few hard runs and tackles to go with Marty would have made a difference, especially as Jensen and Willison do not have big motors (X is improving). Playing Smoothy at lock was a poor decision although he gave it a crack.
Bucking Beads
International Captain
- Mar 5, 2008
- 24,546
- 7,827
Very limited roster spots and we desperately need edge forwards and better depth in the backs
There has been a few things the last month I haven't liked seeing. Against the Warriors Mairner got pushed over the sideline and roughed up over near the fence, no Bronco came over and pushed and told the Warrior to piss off.
If that was Penrith or Storm, 10 of them are over there.
Taupau is playing like his old self again, and it is the version I thought/hoped we would get when we first signed him. For whatever reason, he wasn't playing like this in his previous games, but now that he is, I think he needs to be retained, especially over someone like Baker.
If this form continues, he is more than just a depth signing, and he can be an impact prop off the bench regularly. If he can control his discipline, he offers the aggression and physical presence we desperately need.
His runs off the kickoffs were inspiring, and it was what started generating some momentum for us. In a full strength team, we would likely have had the players to capitalise off the back of his runs.
If this form continues, he is more than just a depth signing, and he can be an impact prop off the bench regularly. If he can control his discipline, he offers the aggression and physical presence we desperately need.
His runs off the kickoffs were inspiring, and it was what started generating some momentum for us. In a full strength team, we would likely have had the players to capitalise off the back of his runs.
Accept
NRL Captain
- Sep 27, 2016
- 3,466
- 3,895
Marty is 35 next year. It would be lunacy to extend his contract. Baker has struggled thus far but that doesn't mean that he will continue to do so. He's also ten years younger. Plenty of time to mature into a reliable member of the engine room.
I think a one year contract is perfectly fine for Taupau, especially given how thin our stocks are. He is only really needed for a 3-6 month period to facilitate the transition of Willison, Te Kura, and any other young prop coming through into regular NRL players. Anything more than a one year contract would be silly.
As for Baker, he's just not it. He will never be anything more than a 5/10, and his average performance will likely always be a 3/10. If he can't offer us a Jensen-like level of value for money, he is of no value to our team. There are better players available for his contract price.
Broncapz
NRL Captain
- May 1, 2016
- 3,004
- 7,066
Marty is the only forward who is able to poke his nose out and get a quick play the ball.
It's nuts, but he's been a big reason why we make more than 40M a set.
- Aug 25, 2018
- 17,984
- 31,047
Marty, or an old head like Marty, is handy to have around all these young forwards.
- Aug 25, 2018
- 17,984
- 31,047
In fairness to Kevvie, we don't know whether he's prepared drop his son yet, but we soon will. It's always been a looming disaster postponed by a few good games last season.
