PRE-GAME [Round 23, 2023] Broncos vs Cowboys

[Foordy]

Cowboys are challenging the grading on Val’s charge. I’m not usually one for conspiracy theories, but i think we all know where this is heading …

I still can't figure out how a 3 week ban (which is the result of a discount due to an early guilty plea) ... Can turn into a zero week ban by getting graded 1 level less

 

[BroncosFever]

Cowboys are challenging the grading on Val’s charge. I’m not usually one for conspiracy theories, but i think we all know where this is heading …

They basically have to, that's 1 mill of their cap on the sidelines if he gets suspended at a crucial point in their season.

 

[broncos4life]

Holmes will be playing us, we have all seen this movie before. It is just a song and dance to make it appear like it’s fair.

 

[Culhwch]

Will he get more if he loses?

 

[Kimlo]

Will he get more if he loses?

3 weeks for guilty plea
4 weeks if he fails
0 weeks if he succeeds in downgrading...

 

[Super Freak]

There are worse that have got Grade 1's so he's got a pretty decent chance of succeeding.

 

[McHunt]

Wow. Did not think they'd try this. Don't like his chances:

"If successful at the judiciary on Tuesday night, he’d miss no footy and be available for the XXXX derby against the Broncos and all of the Cowboys’ run home. If unsuccessful, he’d miss four weeks, which would rule him out of the entire regular season given next week’s bye. He would not play again until week one of the finals if the Cowboys make it."​

 

[Morkel]

What a joke. At this point I wouldn't be surprised if we hear:

"A cowboys teammate has gone in to bat for him, claiming Holmes was actually directing the high shot at one of his teammates, not an opposition player. The video footage appears to back him up, and the judiciary have accepted their version of the events".

 

[mitch222]

What a joke. At this point I wouldn't be surprised if we hear:

"A cowboys teammate has gone in to bat for him, claiming Holmes was actually directing the high shot at one of his teammates, not an opposition player. The video footage appears to back him up, and the judiciary have accepted their version of the events".

Just make sure they dont get Fifita to give testimony or he might **** it up again

 

[BroncsFan]

Holmes will be playing us, we have all seen this movie before. It is just a song and dance to make it appear like it’s fair.

The funny thing is if the judiciary downgrade it to Grade 1, then shouldering someone in the face becomes precedent and never anything more than a fine... as it will have been challenged and accepted by the judiciary.

 

[BroncsFan]

3 weeks for guilty plea
4 weeks if he fails
0 weeks if he succeeds in downgrading...

 

[Organix]

I don't understand how a player can ride Grade 1 careless tackles indefinitely (3 or subsequent) and never see more than a $3k fine (or 2 week suspension if you're a dumbass). Surely you should be punished If you're consistently "careless". At some point it's not being careless anymore, it's poor technique and you should be forced to go away and work on it.

Is this really JWH's 3rd offense, or 4th? I don't keep track, but it's so fishy and he should be forced to be better.

 

[BRC088]

I don't get the whole fight and fail and get more time thing, if its worth 4 week, give them 4 weeks..

 

[_wwong]

Cowboys are challenging the grading on Val’s charge. I’m not usually one for conspiracy theories, but i think we all know where this is heading …

He’ll serve his suspension in the off season.

 

[Super Freak]

 

[JayPee]

Hitting him with the upper part of his arm is going to save him. It is not worse than JWHs. That's probably why they are challenging it. That and Campbell lowering slightly and getting back up. I dont understand how you go from 3 weeks to 0 though. It's probably worth 1 week atleast and 2 because of his record.

I have been alive for 30 years and for as long as I can remember we have had the same problems with these muppets being inconsistent week to week. Can never get it 100% right but jesus.

 

[ivanhungryjak]

I don't get the whole fight and fail and get more time thing, if its worth 4 week, give them 4 weeks..

It’s like the Court system - you get a discount for pleading it out early. Saves the time and effort of a hearing, etc.

 

[Culhwch]

I don't understand how a player can ride Grade 1 careless tackles indefinitely (3 or subsequent) and never see more than a $3k fine (or 2 week suspension if you're a dumbass). Surely you should be punished If you're consistently "careless". At some point it's not being careless anymore, it's poor technique and you should be forced to go away and work on it.

Is this really JWH's 3rd offense, or 4th? I don't keep track, but it's so fishy and he should be forced to be better.

It's not his go. Good bloke, JWH.