PRE-GAME [Round 4, 2022] Warriors vs Broncos

Status
Not open for further replies.
McHunt said:
Johns makes an interesting comment here. He (and Fitler) think Selwyn should go to fullback (we already knew that), but adds the reservation that he doesn't talk. It's a little hard to tell whether he means Tesi or Selwyn, but I'm pretty sure it's Selwyn:



It looks like a problem right across the park to me, and might explain why they all seem to be playing their own games. There's clearly no communication between Staggs and Cobbo, Farnworth and Oates, or Tesi and anyone. Correct me if you think I'm wrong but I haven't detected any.

Perhaps someone who's been to a match this year might weigh in.
Click to expand...

haven't seen much chat at all mate... when we were camped on our line with few drop outs vs the cows it was capes doing all the talking
 
BroncosFever said:
Walters is happy with him, he's obviously doing something right.
Click to expand...
I agree somewhat! KWs closer to the action, knows the 'vibe' and is doubtless a better judge than I. Still I cannot help wonder why go forward is not important especially when our lack of it has been repeatedly mentioned by all and sundry. I'm referring to our bench here. Anyway, I will see what we get from James starting if that eventuates.
 
JAHHW said:
I don’t care about James, Boyd, Turpin, Kennedy or anyone else.

Like I said, when people were excusing Boyd for contributing shit numbers because he was a good communicator or a good leader (which I still doubt, as the proof really is in the pudding), why weren’t you criticising him like you are James? Indeed, you, unlike almost every other person who saw Boyd’s final few seasons, thought his contributions were good, to the point you declared he was one of our best. The bloke was a passenger, a meme, yet somehow you thought he was good. You defended Boyd for the same things you’re criticising James for now.

There’s your hypocrisy.

But if you still don’t understand how you’re being a hypocrite, to use a Huge-ism: like Isaako, Boyd and every other plodder (like James is) you’ve defended, Walters keeps selecting James (like Barrett and Stuart before him and like Holbrook just did with Isaako - remember the old thread you reignited on Tuesday because Isaako was selected by Holbrook…), so he obviously sees something in him.
Click to expand...
You see, this is where you misunderstood my point of view. I only said he played well in his final season not that he was always in good form. I've also acknowledged KW is a better judge than I am but it doesn't mean I agree with all his decisions. I also had different reasons for Boyd than James as they played quite different roles. I don't think it can be argued that a prop doesn't need to provide go forward for the team and this is my issue with James. 107 metres in as many minutes over three games is truly dreadful.
 
JAHHW said:
I don’t care about James, Boyd, Turpin, Kennedy or anyone else.

Like I said, when people were excusing Boyd for contributing shit numbers because he was a good communicator or a good leader (which I still doubt, as the proof really is in the pudding), why weren’t you criticising him like you are James? Indeed, you, unlike almost every other person who saw Boyd’s final few seasons, thought his contributions were good, to the point you declared he was one of our best. The bloke was a passenger, a meme, yet somehow you thought he was good. You defended Boyd for the same things you’re criticising James for now.

There’s your hypocrisy.

But if you still don’t understand how you’re being a hypocrite, to use a Huge-ism: like Isaako, Boyd and every other plodder (like James is) you’ve defended, Walters keeps selecting James (like Barrett and Stuart before him and like Holbrook just did with Isaako - remember the old thread you reignited on Tuesday because Isaako was selected by Holbrook…), so he obviously sees something in him.
Click to expand...
What I would say is Boyd is a good leader just like Glenn was. People might not want to believe that, but the other players wouldn't back blokes who don't offer something. What I do think though is that doesn't make them a good captain, which on the field they clearly didn't show they were. Leadership comes in all different forms. We have really been lacking an on field leader more than anything since Locky.
 
theshed said:
Well that settles it. He’s good enough for a Walters team list.
Click to expand...

You are most likely being sarcastic, none of us know any better.

The same with Cobbo at fullback, if you were watching QLD Cup last year you'd be ripping your hair out wondering why he's not the fullback in our NRL team.. that was until Walters gave him that opportunity in a trial and he was found wanting in basic effort areas.

Kevvie sees all these things that us mugs don't.
 
BroncosFever said:
You are most likely being sarcastic, none of us know any better.

The same with Cobbo at fullback, if you were watching QLD Cup last year you'd be ripping your hair out wondering why he's not the fullback in our NRL team.. that was until Walters gave him that opportunity in a trial and he was found wanting in basic effort areas.

Kevvie sees all these things that us mugs don't.
Click to expand...

Plenty of players have carved up ISC but can't translate it to NRL. Look at Isaako on our own doorstep.
 
BroncosFever said:
You are most likely being sarcastic, none of us know any better.

The same with Cobbo at fullback, if you were watching QLD Cup last year you'd be ripping your hair out wondering why he's not the fullback in our NRL team.. that was until Walters gave him that opportunity in a trial and he was found wanting in basic effort areas.

Kevvie sees all these things that us mugs don't.
Click to expand...

Not really, in ISC he just ran and made breaks- He had two try assists in his 9 games at fullback. That was never going to be an NRL fullback in '22. I repeatedly said it over summer. He hasn't shown any NRL fullback qualities.

Cobbo's passing improved his second stint in ISC. His two try assists were in the last round and prelim final.

The breakdown of receipts and passing/running was 77 passes/230 times he touched the ball in 10 games.
 
Brenko rotating in for Kotoni at right centre.

Who is rotating in for Riki ?

Kotoni to 2nd row ?
 
Wolfie said:
Dunno mate. He hasn't played there much but tbh I've always thought he would end up there. I've been pretty vocal in the past I think it could be his best position, so he will probably stay at center and kill it 😄
Click to expand...
I thought he'd be taller.

Screenshot 2022-03-31 at 14-10-40 Kotoni Staggs - Wikipedia.png


en.wikipedia.org

Kotoni Staggs - Wikipedia

en.wikipedia.org en.wikipedia.org
 
Alex Wingnut said:
Jokes aside a lot of people think he's tall for some reason. He's listed as 6'1 which is just bs I've met him (I'm 6'3) and he's 5'11 maybe 6'0 at best.

He's just a fast twitch power nugget.
Click to expand...
I would have said he is about 6ft. I have always and still thought he could be a better back rower than a center.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
New Posts

Unread

Watch

YouTube
0 0 1,047
1:20:38
NRL Preliminary Final, 1998 - Brisbane Broncos vs Sydney City Roosters
View full media list »

Active Now

Total: 81 (members: 4, guests: 77)
Robots: 121
Top
  AdBlock Message
Please consider adding BHQ to your Adblock Whitelist. We do our best to make sure it doesn't affect your experience on the website, and the funds help us pay server and software costs.