Round 5 Discussion

And then Bulldogs were denied a chance to win the game when Morris was pushed in the back to stop him from going for the ball which is illegal.

I don't blame the Bulldogs fans for being pissed off.
 
Just on Channel 9 news.

A fan taken to hospital after the game, after being king hit by a Bulldogs fans.

FFS. Some of their fans are feral.
 
That was a very sad end to what was a quality game. Graham was simply trying to charge down a kick and he even called for the medical staff to assist Reynolds and Reynolds wasn't even in the air, I thought it was bullshit.

I feel very sorry for the Bulldogs they were robbed and didn't deserve to lose that game.
 
Unbelievable.

I knew something was up when 9 started skipping all the breaks but I couldn't believe that finish.

Wow...

On the positive note, how good were the bench forwards for both teams? David Klemmer & Chris Grevsmuhl offered so much to both their sides and the future is looking very bright.
 
Broncoman said:
That was a very sad end to what was a quality game. Graham was simply trying to charge down a kick and he even called for the medical staff to assist Reynolds and Reynolds wasn't even in the air, I thought it was bullshit.

I feel very sorry for the Bulldogs they were robbed and didn't deserve to lose that game.
Click to expand...

I've seen a lot of Roosters fans with the same opinion.
 
Did you notice that the clock stopped on 76.34 after the field goal ? It remained there for the entire set of six for the Dogs and then they kicked for touch..the time,still on 76.34. Then Souths got the ball from the scrum and in total, according to the time clock ,only 45 seconds had passed ! A whole set of six tackles, a stoppage for the scrum and then a scrum win,all in 45 seconds. Souths should never had had the chance to win that game. I'd be screaming if I were a dogs supporter aside from the ridiculous penalty...
 
Big Pete said:
Unbelievable.

I knew something was up when 9 started skipping all the breaks but I couldn't believe that finish.
Click to expand...

Haha, caught the game on Livestream thanks to Nine being dicks as usual.

Only one more week of DST screwing around, we could bloody well use it here in the SE corner :mmph:

@Huge, TV clock often isn't in sync with the game clock at the stadium.
 
Last edited:
vertigo said:
Haha, caught the game on Livestream thanks to Nine being dicks as usual.

Only one more week of DST screwing around, we could bloody well use it here in the SE corner :mmph:

@Huge, TV clock often isn't in sync with the game clock at the stadium.
Click to expand...
Yeah I know but in this case the game clock as indicated on the screen was in sync and the game finished at exactly the same moment as the tv screen clock. Check it out, he'll,you could even time it yourself but the clock showed at the kickoff after the field goal 76.34. When Souths regained the ball only 45/50 seconds had passed...I'm surprised no one else has seen that. Nevertheless, the tv clock may have run on earlier ( perhaps unnoticed)and they simply held the tv clock until it was in proper sync with the actual ground clock so you may well be right, I may be totally wrong
 
Klemmer and Graham should hopefully both cop a few weeks.

I thought the tackle was worthy of a penalty, though the injury was a bit of a freak occurrence.

But two props fronting up, getting in the face of a referee? Not on.

Hope they cop additional punishment for the bottle shower too. Disgraceful shit. Family club my ass.
 
From the NRL site

Dangerous contact on field goal: the rule explained
There was much confusion after lead referee Gerard Sutton handed South Sydney a penalty in front of the sticks when halfback Adam Reynolds' leg was taken out on a James Graham chargedown. Referees boss Tony Archer fronted the media post-game to explain the rule.

"If there is an unsuccessful field goal attempt, and there is an infringement on the kicker, that penalty is awarded 10 metres out from in front of the goal posts," he said.

"That's why they went to that position for the penalty. It's not where the ball bounces, which is just from a general play kick. That was the difference in it."

Whether the penalty should have been awarded or not, Archer was unwilling to say.

"It's really difficult for me to comment because the player has been placed on report for the dangerous contact, and there obviously has to be a process that has to occur in relation to that," he said.


Bulldogs v Rabbitohs: Five key points - NRL.com


Also

Maguire also confirmed that he had been made aware of an incident involving Josh Reynolds in the dying stages of the match. The Belmore No. 6 is alleged to have hurled a kicking tee at the injured halfback as he hobbled back across halfway.


http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sp...in-over-bulldogs/story-fni3fbgz-1227290589773
 
Last edited:
Kaz said:
Also

Maguire also confirmed that he had been made aware of an incident involving Josh Reynolds in the dying stages of the match. The Belmore No. 6 is alleged to have hurled a kicking tee at the injured halfback as he hobbled back across halfway.
Click to expand...

But he just wants to play football! Everyone is picking on him.
 
Kaz said:
From the NRL site

Dangerous contact on field goal: the rule explained
There was much confusion after lead referee Gerard Sutton handed South Sydney a penalty in front of the sticks when halfback Adam Reynolds' leg was taken out on a James Graham chargedown. Referees boss Tony Archer fronted the media post-game to explain the rule.

"If there is an unsuccessful field goal attempt, and there is an infringement on the kicker, that penalty is awarded 10 metres out from in front of the goal posts," he said.

"That's why they went to that position for the penalty. It's not where the ball bounces, which is just from a general play kick. That was the difference in it."

Whether the penalty should have been awarded or not, Archer was unwilling to say.

"It's really difficult for me to comment because the player has been placed on report for the dangerous contact, and there obviously has to be a process that has to occur in relation to that," he said.


Bulldogs v Rabbitohs: Five key points - NRL.com


Also

Maguire also confirmed that he had been made aware of an incident involving Josh Reynolds in the dying stages of the match. The Belmore No. 6 is alleged to have hurled a kicking tee at the injured halfback as he hobbled back across halfway.


http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sp...in-over-bulldogs/story-fni3fbgz-1227290589773
Click to expand...

Oh no the NRL is targeting him again, call Danny Wiedler
 
Last edited:
The best NYC player of 2015 makes his debut for Manly.

Tom Trbojevic on the wing.
 
Kaz said:
From the NRL site

Dangerous contact on field goal: the rule explained
There was much confusion after lead referee Gerard Sutton handed South Sydney a penalty in front of the sticks when halfback Adam Reynolds' leg was taken out on a James Graham chargedown. Referees boss Tony Archer fronted the media post-game to explain the rule.

"If there is an unsuccessful field goal attempt, and there is an infringement on the kicker, that penalty is awarded 10 metres out from in front of the goal posts," he said.

"That's why they went to that position for the penalty. It's not where the ball bounces, which is just from a general play kick. That was the difference in it."

Whether the penalty should have been awarded or not, Archer was unwilling to say.

"It's really difficult for me to comment because the player has been placed on report for the dangerous contact, and there obviously has to be a process that has to occur in relation to that," he said.


Bulldogs v Rabbitohs: Five key points - NRL.com


Also

Maguire also confirmed that he had been made aware of an incident involving Josh Reynolds in the dying stages of the match. The Belmore No. 6 is alleged to have hurled a kicking tee at the injured halfback as he hobbled back across halfway.


http://www.dailytelegraph.com.au/sp...in-over-bulldogs/story-fni3fbgz-1227290589773
Click to expand...
yeah saw the grub throw it one of the Souths players but didn't know who it was
 
Lol Manly.

What the **** is going on at the club? They have been awful this year. Even the 2013-14 Broncos performed better than this..
 
New Posts

Unread

Watch

YouTube
0 0 740
1:21:59
NSWRL Round 16, 1988 - Manly Sea Eagles vs Brisbane Broncos
View full media list »

Active Now

  • Harry Sack
  • BrentTatesChin
  • RolledOates
  • Loch Ness Monster
  • Xzei
  • Foordy
  • Fozz
  • Marty Deutschmann
Total: 105 (members: 12, guests: 93)
Robots: 289
Top
  AdBlock Message
Please consider adding BHQ to your Adblock Whitelist. We do our best to make sure it doesn't affect your experience on the website, and the funds help us pay server and software costs.