Alec
International Rep
- Mar 4, 2008
- 19,400
- 12,528
Yeah, I think Carrigan is gone. He looked good in his limited time, but looks behind Flegler in the pecking order.
Well from what I can tell he offers basically no impact off the bench. He probably has to be a starting lock to be worth having in the team.Yeah, I think Carrigan is gone. He looked good in his limited time, but looks behind Flegler in the pecking order.
Love this team... But it won't happen. I'd be tempted to swap dearden for sos but know it probably isn't the best thing for his or our future throwing him in this early. Also, it's gotten to the point where if we swap the team around now our confidence is so low we would lose anyway, then where do we go from there? I think this team deserves the losses we are getting, they need to either dig us out of it or at the end of the year we subsidise 50% of their contracts (boyd, macca) and get rid of them or tell them they are bench or nothing (Knik). The 1 or 2 changes we make don't deserve to be thrown to the wolves with this shit unit with its atrocious leadership...1 Bird
2 Oates
3 Roberts
4 Staggs
5 Boyd
6 Milf
7 SoS
8 Lodge
9 Macca
10 Haas
11 Fifita
12 Gillett
13 Carrigan
14 Nikorima
15 Flegler
16 TPJ
17 Glenn
Simple.
Carrigan was actually pretty good off the bench. Not what you'd call an impact player, but he made good ground and defended well. I'd have he and Flegler comfortably ahead of S'Ua in the pecking order.
Well from what I can tell he offers basically no impact off the bench. He probably has to be a starting lock to be worth having in the team.
Our forward pack is full of soft ***** who roll over
The sharks are battle hardened
They will roll right over us next week like every other fucking team in the comp
Even if Su'a is out, there's only room for one, unless Ofa gets dropped too.
Im just saying from what ive seen hes more in the workhorse model than an impact player. Unless he is starting, Ithink Flegler and Sua can offer a bit more punch.So he has no impact, but averages over 10m a run, and has a tackle efficiency of over 90%
Ok then.
Well from what I can tell he offers basically no impact off the bench. He probably has to be a starting lock to be worth having in the team.
I have also said multiple times "from what ive seen" etc. I've only seen his NRL games, and as you've said, minimal minutes. I guess I just don't remember seeing him break the line whilst Flegler has once or twice gone for like a 20m run and Sua did some good things last year.Tough call on a guy with about 45 mins of nrl under the belt
1 Bird
2 Oates
3 Roberts
4 Staggs
5 Boyd
6 Milf
7 SoS
8 Lodge
9 Macca
10 Haas
11 Fifita
12 Gillett
13 Carrigan
14 Nikorima
15 Flegler
16 TPJ
17 Glenn
Simple.
I have also said multiple times "from what ive seen" etc. I've only seen his NRL games, and as you've said, minimal minutes. I guess I just don't remember seeing him break the line whilst Flegler has once or twice gone for like a 20m run and Sua did some good things last year.
I think Joffa has been a bit off his game. Maybe have him on the bench instead of Glenn in my team, or at lock instead of Patty. Joffa was quality at lock last year.
Who’s going to be goal kicker for this team? This week I don’t think Isaako made any errors and his goal kicking is our best, so probably he won’t get dropped in any way.This team might have a chance:
1. Bird
2. Oates
3. Staggs
4. Roberts
5. Boyd
6. Milford
7. Nikorima
8. Lodge
9. McCollough (horrible but who else)?
10. Haas
11. Gillett
12. Fifita
13. Pangi
14. Glenn
15. Flegler
16. Su’a
17. Offa