Broncapz
NRL Player
- May 1, 2016
- 2,970
- 6,984
heartly87
NRL Player
- May 10, 2014
- 1,904
- 5,161
@Wolfie can you elaborate why mate? I agree with you on a lot of things but this one is a struggle for me to understand. Out of all the choices that are legitimate, how is this the one you can't fathom?
Bucking Beads
International Captain
- Mar 5, 2008
- 24,269
- 7,572
My concern is that we think a coach will save us. There is obviously other issues at the club that I hope are getting addressed at the club. Couldn’t care less who coaches us if we’re winning premierships
Broncapz
NRL Player
- May 1, 2016
- 2,970
- 6,984
Foordy
International Captain
Contributor
- Mar 4, 2008
- 34,690
- 41,304
Funnily enough, his first 4 years as Lions coach was very similar to Kevvie's 4 years at the Bronx
Bucking Beads
International Captain
- Mar 5, 2008
- 24,269
- 7,572
Obviously but it would be a fatal error to consider it our only problem that needs to be addressed
Wolfie
International Captain
- Jan 14, 2015
- 23,584
- 38,907
My main issue i simply just dont like the bloke.
Its not that i cant see what he possibly could bring. If we want an experienced coach, i think we are looking at him or Brad Arthur. I'd prefer Arthur out of the two, but neither really fill me with any confidence. I think right now, Madge's stock is higher based on him doing decent with NZ and NSW beating our weakened Queensland team. He hasnt been a good club level coach since 2015, which is a fair while ago now.
Also, while i dont agree this would be fair, if he doesnt hit the ground running, the daggers are going to be out for him considering his background. He's a vastly experienced head coach who will ( if he gets the job ) be inheriting a side more than capable of finishing top 6, if not higher. If he cant deliver that we will probably be looking at another coach this time next year.
heartly87
NRL Player
- May 10, 2014
- 1,904
- 5,161
Yelling has never been intimidating. The yelling from Bellyache is about his passion and desire to win at all costs. So you respect it and him for his passion and drive to be the best. I doubt any of these coaches go in there thinking they are going to scare a bunch of muscled up athletes haha.
heartly87
NRL Player
- May 10, 2014
- 1,904
- 5,161
Thanks for the answer. I get it, we all don't like the same people. Honestly haven't seen an interview I dislike him from.
Win win. We can get back on the road to a prem and QLD will have the shield for the next three years.
heartly87
NRL Player
- May 10, 2014
- 1,904
- 5,161
I get it, we can't like the same type of people I guess. I have actually liked him everytime I have heard him on podcasts/radio ect. Seems to have a good grasp on the game.
I agree there are risks with this one but I think they are worth taking. I would have gone Flanno who you also from memory despise haha. Arthur would be my second out of who is available and ready day one. But for me I would only see him as another stop gap coach. A Hook 2.0 who will have us playing well and being there abouts each year but never really getting us home. Madge is either a decade of success guy or quick out the door mistake. I am willing to take the punt on him being ready to bring this club back to the winning fold.
Wolfie
International Captain
- Jan 14, 2015
- 23,584
- 38,907
I dont think i have a strong opinion on Flanno tbh. Not his biggest fan, but i would take him over the other 2!
Manofoneway
NRL Player
- May 22, 2022
- 2,185
- 5,198
If we have the same injuries i reckon we have the same outcomes. Just my personal opinion.
heartly87
NRL Player
- May 10, 2014
- 1,904
- 5,161
Sorry for my weird double post BHQ. Was trying to reply on my phone while attempting to rock my 18 month old, who woke up bellowing. Should know I can't do two things at once haha
Manofoneway
NRL Player
- May 22, 2022
- 2,185
- 5,198
Also if we hire Flanno he is likely going to sign his mediocre son. Mchunt will probably rock up to the Clive Berghofer centre in a suicide vest or something if that happens.
BroncosFever
State of Origin Rep
- Jun 6, 2014
- 6,063
- 10,852
Brad Arthur and his son, Jake.
Manofoneway
NRL Player
- May 22, 2022
- 2,185
- 5,198
I can see the news story now. "21 year old male named Bruce Mchunt, 65kgs with fish bowl glasses wearing a "PAIX TAKES THE CAKE" Tshirt has stormed the Clive Berghofer centre with a makeshift suicide vest."
Foordy
International Captain
Contributor
- Mar 4, 2008
- 34,690
- 41,304
This is a tough one.
However, I think one thing is clear, the Brisbane Broncos are not a club that can go with a rookie coach. the pressure and the expectation from both the fans and media, make this role the hardest head coaching role in Aussie sport. It's too much for a coach with their L-plates on to handle.
so for me that leaves us with 3 options: Michael Maguire, Brad Arthur or Shaun Wane. so let's take a look at them a bit more closely.
Michael Maguire.
NRL Premiership, Challenge Cup (ESL), Super League Premiership, Pacific Championship (NZ), State of Origin winner
Winning %: Wigan = 76% | Souths = 56% | Tigers = 36%
Madge has taken control of some high profile clubs both in Australia and England and had plenty of success doing it. He lead Wigan to their first GF in 7 years and first premiership in 10 years.
Then he came back to Australia and lead Souths to their first title in 43 years.
yes he failed at the Tigers, but so did Ivan Cleary and he is about to be involved in his 5th straight GF (he's won 3 straight so far). so take out the Tigers stats and he has a career winning % of 61.9%.
Brad Arthur
Coached in 5 finals series (in 10 years) at the Eels. Coached in 1 GF (2022)
Winning %: Eels = 52% and Leeds = 50% (only 10 games)
He took over the Eels at a particularly poor time for the club. (coming in after they won several consecutive wooden spoons).
He did a decent job rebuilding the club despite the constant boardroom battles. turned them into a competitive outfit (most years), but IMO isn't capable of taking the next step.
Shaun Wane
3 x Super League Premierships, 2 x Challenge Cup Titles
Winning %: Wigan = 68%
although he is untried at NRL level, he took over from Madge at Wigan, which is the closest to expectation and pressure to the Broncos as can be found outside Australia.
in 7 years at the helm of the Warriors he lead them to 5 titles (3 Premierships and 2 cup titles) which is impressive.
he's also had success as a rep coach taking charge after Bennett in 2020 and has an 80% winning record from 10 games in charge to date.
Verdict:
my vote to replace Kevvie is Michael Maguire. I think he is the most likely to handle the role placate the fans by bring success to the team fairly quickly.
p.s. Matty Johns says he'll get us a premiership within 2 years. hopefully he's on the mark if Madge gets the gig
However, I think one thing is clear, the Brisbane Broncos are not a club that can go with a rookie coach. the pressure and the expectation from both the fans and media, make this role the hardest head coaching role in Aussie sport. It's too much for a coach with their L-plates on to handle.
so for me that leaves us with 3 options: Michael Maguire, Brad Arthur or Shaun Wane. so let's take a look at them a bit more closely.
Michael Maguire.
NRL Premiership, Challenge Cup (ESL), Super League Premiership, Pacific Championship (NZ), State of Origin winner
Winning %: Wigan = 76% | Souths = 56% | Tigers = 36%
Madge has taken control of some high profile clubs both in Australia and England and had plenty of success doing it. He lead Wigan to their first GF in 7 years and first premiership in 10 years.
Then he came back to Australia and lead Souths to their first title in 43 years.
yes he failed at the Tigers, but so did Ivan Cleary and he is about to be involved in his 5th straight GF (he's won 3 straight so far). so take out the Tigers stats and he has a career winning % of 61.9%.
Brad Arthur
Coached in 5 finals series (in 10 years) at the Eels. Coached in 1 GF (2022)
Winning %: Eels = 52% and Leeds = 50% (only 10 games)
He took over the Eels at a particularly poor time for the club. (coming in after they won several consecutive wooden spoons).
He did a decent job rebuilding the club despite the constant boardroom battles. turned them into a competitive outfit (most years), but IMO isn't capable of taking the next step.
Shaun Wane
3 x Super League Premierships, 2 x Challenge Cup Titles
Winning %: Wigan = 68%
although he is untried at NRL level, he took over from Madge at Wigan, which is the closest to expectation and pressure to the Broncos as can be found outside Australia.
in 7 years at the helm of the Warriors he lead them to 5 titles (3 Premierships and 2 cup titles) which is impressive.
he's also had success as a rep coach taking charge after Bennett in 2020 and has an 80% winning record from 10 games in charge to date.
Verdict:
my vote to replace Kevvie is Michael Maguire. I think he is the most likely to handle the role placate the fans by bring success to the team fairly quickly.
p.s. Matty Johns says he'll get us a premiership within 2 years. hopefully he's on the mark if Madge gets the gig
N
nopatience101
NRL Captain
- Mar 4, 2008
- 3,462
- 6,308
The WT were never a good fit for Madge, where we are right now, we are the perfect fit imo.
