Who was better?

[Kimlo]

El Masri (queue the bias calls :P), he just had an incredible ability of being in the right place at the right time, it's a shame he didn't get to play more fullback because he was far better there than at wing.

Josh Morris or Brett Morris?

 

[Coxy]

Josh. More capable of making something happen. Brett just a finisher.

Dale shearer or Kerry boustead?

 

[GCBRONCO]

Kerry Boustead, Dale Shearer was made for SOO but was inconsistent as a player at club level.

Gary Belcher or Colin Scott?

 

[Mister Wright]

Didn't see a lot of Colin Scott, saw plenty of Belcher - rated him highly, so will go with Belcher.

Brad Thorn or Bradley Clyde?

 

[Coxy]

Clyde. I loved Thorny, absolute legend and competitor. But Clyde was more skillful and just as strong a defender, and more agile laterally.

Julian O'Neill or Karmichael Hunt

 

[Porthoz]

As much as I hate him, Khunt was a better and more complete player...

Lewis or Lockyer?

 

[Kaz]

Lockyer, because he dominated at all levels. NRL, Tests & Origin.

Lewis was great in the BRL, Tests & Origin, but not as great in the NRL.

Steve Walters or Ben Elias.

 

[Mister Wright]

Steve Walters. Benny was good, but Walters easily better.

Brett Mullins or Michael Hancock?

 

[Big Pete]

Mullins

Hancock has longevity but Mullins at his best was just on another level. His ability to swerve and bamboozle defenders was great to watch and there was a period around 94-95 where he was the best attacking weapon in the game. Hancock was a handy, determined runner but was never quite the best.

Benji Marshall vs. Stacey Jones

 

[Coxy]

Mullins

Han**** has longevity but Mullins at his best was just on another level. His ability to swerve and bamboozle defenders was great to watch and there was a period around 94-95 where he was the best attacking weapon in the game. Han**** was a handy, determined runner but was never quite the best.

Benji Marshall vs. Stacey Jones

Jones by a mile. Marshall has the better individual game, but Jones was a great organiser, great visionary, and wasn't as much of a turnstile in defence like Marshall.

Brett Kimmorley or Matt Orford

 

[Broncoman]

Noddy. Brett was one of the most important players in any team he played for and was a strong performer for NSW and Australia.

Farah V Ennis

 

[Ari Gold]

Farah. He's much more creative and I think origin showed he's just as tough.

Scott Minto or Stuart Kelly?

 

[Broncoman]

Kelly. He could hold down a first grade spot and wasn't a bad player from memory. He also played Origin as well.

Nathan Blacklock V Nathan Merritt

 

[Alec]

Blacklock. He didn't play for Souffs.

Darren Lockyer vs Billy Slater.

 

[Meat77]

Lockyer. Dominated two positions and was inspirational every time he took the field.

Ewen McGrady or Brent Sherwin?

 

[Kimlo]

Lockyer, best in the world in two positions and IMO Lockyer at his peak is equal if not better to Slater at fullback.

Thurston vs Smith?

 

[Mister Wright]

Smith - Hands down. While Rhurston is great, he can have a poor game from time-to-time. However, Smith rarely has a bad game.

Anthony Mundine or Brett Finch?

 

[Porthoz]

Brett Finch, although my dislike of Mundine may toil my view...

Ben Barba or Matty Bowen?