Who was better?

[Broncoman]

You sure picked a toughie for me. Maloney because he adds more in attack and is underrated as a half, while Pearce is overrated by some members of the media and former players, he is just a first-grader nothing more.

 

[Mister Wright]

To keep it going:

Fatty Vautin or Peter Sterling?

 

[Fozz]

Sterlo. He's not a total fwit and he didn't play for Manly even if he did play for NSW.

Dane Gagai or Dale Copley?

 

[Porthoz]

Copley for his slow, but constant improvement, and not being a dickhead! Although Gagai may overtake him in the future...

Alex Glenn or Shaun Berrigan?

 

[Coxy]

Berrigan. Both are versatile, but Berrigan managed to be nearly as effective no matter where you put him. Glenn I think is now a specialist back rower.

Leon Bott or Denan Kemp

 

[Kimlo]

Kemp because 2008. (or maybe 2007 if I have my years confused.)

 

[Porthoz]

Luke Priddis or Danny Buderus?

 

[Coxy]

Buderus. He made Andrew Johns look good. As great as I think Priddis was, especially for the Broncos and Panthers, Buderus had a slight edge in skill.

Chris Johns or Josh Morris

 

[Meat77]

Johns. He was a complete centre - Morris is good with the ball in his hands and not much else

Tolsen Tollett or Stu Galbraith?

 

[Mister Wright]

Who & Who?

 

[Meat77]

Both played halfback for parramatta in the 90's. Galbraith was the half when they beat us in the first game at ANZ

 

[Kimlo]

Well moving on, Thaiday Vs Glenn

 

[Coxy]

At this point in their careers, Thaiday. But I suspect Glenn will be a better, more complete player when we analyse them both post-retirement.

Terry Lamb or Geoff Toovey?

 

[simmo77]

Lamb for sure.

Peachey or Blacklock?

 

[Mister Wright]

Peachey. Very slick player.

E.T. or Renouf?

 

[Big Pete]

ET, more versatile player who was good in all grades. Renouf was a great attacking centre, but like Jennings if he wasn't fed good ball he could be MIA.

Ikin or Wallace

 

[Broncoman]

Ikin. Was a far better allround player and could play more than 1 position. Shane Webcke v Glenn Lazarus

 

[pennywisealfie]

Webcke all the way.

Dean Schifilliti or Neil Pincinelli?