Mitch06
NRL Player
- Jan 23, 2014
- 1,580
- 580
Surely you don't think Reed should be in there...
Worst ever Broncos XIII
- Thread starter Super Freak
- Start date
Black Philip
State of Origin Captain
- Mar 5, 2008
- 9,600
- 1,305
I'd have Shane Tronc over Clinton at prop. He was one of the most ineffective forwards I've seen at the club.
- Mar 4, 2008
- 10,566
- 5,415
He had his good moments. But he was nothing in attack. That was fine because he was a beast in defence at first, but his last two seasons his defence was poor.
- Jan 25, 2014
- 44,777
- 34,165
- Thread starter
- #23
- Sep 6, 2013
- 57,570
- 70,479
Clinton essentially replaced Petero, in any sense, that was an absolutely absurd decision. Whoever made that call should be shot.
- Sep 6, 2013
- 57,570
- 70,479
I honestly didn't think Gorrell was that bad. Roberts, meh.
Marsh was an ex-rep player who came with fairly big expectations and was just past it, he offered nothing that his reputation (whatever it was worth) warranted.
GCBRONCO
International Captain
- Mar 4, 2008
- 22,921
- 21,379
Who was also being outclassed by Nick Kenny, Clinton was highly rated at the Panthers, but he was a dud at the Broncos and given that profile I would have him in that side ahead of Tronc, people complain about how our pack is now.....
IMO qualifying players should have a minimum game amount too, 1-10 games doesn't really provide an accurate representation of a quality as a player.
Last edited:
- Apr 9, 2012
- 12,917
- 14,659
Taylor1921
QCup Player
- Apr 18, 2014
- 833
- 470
Pet
Peter Wallace was very good for us
mitch222
State of Origin Captain
- Apr 4, 2014
- 8,824
- 8,956
1. Josh Hoffman - Hoffman on the wing was solid as ****, Hoffman at fullback yeah nah
2. Dale Copley - Had so much potential but never lived up to it. He had a few good games but lost us quite a few games off his own bat including a semi final against Manly
3. Aaron Whitchurch - dick for fingers is putting it nicely
4. Greg Eden - Almost slipped over just writing his name
5. Kane Manihera
6. Ben Barba - A spud signing from the beginning. Never looked like even a quarter of the player he was at the Dogs
7. Luke Capewell - Felt sorry for him. Good enough to be a standout in NSW Cup/QLD but didnt have the ability to step up to first grade
8. Martin Kennedy - What a powderpuff
9. Aaron Gorrel - meh
10. Mitchell Garbutt - Highly rated signing to begin with, spud worthy contribution. Biggest note in career to date, punching Tamou in the WCC
11. Dunamis Lui
12. Lagi Setu
13. Palmer Waupau
14. David Hala - what a massive disappointment he was. Put up big numbers in the gym but never delivered on the field.
15. Lama Tasi
16. Scott Anderson
17. Guy Williams
2. Dale Copley - Had so much potential but never lived up to it. He had a few good games but lost us quite a few games off his own bat including a semi final against Manly
3. Aaron Whitchurch - dick for fingers is putting it nicely
4. Greg Eden - Almost slipped over just writing his name
5. Kane Manihera
6. Ben Barba - A spud signing from the beginning. Never looked like even a quarter of the player he was at the Dogs
7. Luke Capewell - Felt sorry for him. Good enough to be a standout in NSW Cup/QLD but didnt have the ability to step up to first grade
8. Martin Kennedy - What a powderpuff
9. Aaron Gorrel - meh
10. Mitchell Garbutt - Highly rated signing to begin with, spud worthy contribution. Biggest note in career to date, punching Tamou in the WCC
11. Dunamis Lui
12. Lagi Setu
13. Palmer Waupau
14. David Hala - what a massive disappointment he was. Put up big numbers in the gym but never delivered on the field.
15. Lama Tasi
16. Scott Anderson
17. Guy Williams
- Sep 6, 2013
- 57,570
- 70,479
Yep he certainly was at times. I remember in one of those seasons messed up by Lockyer's knee pop, Wallace carried the Broncs.
- Sep 6, 2013
- 57,570
- 70,479
Very harsh on Parfitt and Vidot. They weren't superstars by any means but there were definitely worse wingers than Dan and Parfitt never really got a shot. I reckon he could have been a success if given the opportunity.
Accept
NRL Captain
- Sep 27, 2016
- 3,467
- 3,897
Very slow in the defensive line and seemed to be a little out of his depth. I agree though, he was treated shabbily by Hook.
Accept
NRL Captain
- Sep 27, 2016
- 3,467
- 3,897
Name me a worse winger than Vidot.
