BHQ Countdown: Most Loved/Least Liked Players Reveal thread

[pennywisealfie]

NSW Edition of pennywisealfie Countdown

BHQ Loved

33. Luke Priddis

1999-2001
Position: Hooker
Games: 79
Tries: 17
Highest Vote: 9 (Sproj)

BHQ Loathed

33. Payne Haas

2018-
Position: Front Row
Games: 81
Tries: 7
Highest Vote: 1 (Accept)

 

[Allo]

Priddis was only 3 years?

Felt like he was our hooker from like 98 til like 04

Mind you that's my kid-brain memory talking

 

[ningnangnong]

Still gutted Priddis left.

We've never really replaced him to be honest.

 

[I bleed Maroon]

@Accept has no chill with Haas lol

 

[Sproj]

Priddis was the best 9 we’ve ever had, there I said it. He was an absolute gun, letting him go turned out to be a real error from the club.

I thought Haas would be higher up the hated list, the stunt he pulled last year was disgraceful. And now, we’ve gone all in on him and I just can’t see him sticking around once the Henny Pennys come knocking and they will.

 

[Foordy]

Priddis was the best 9 we’ve ever had, there I said it. He was an absolute gun, letting him go turned out to be a real error from the club.

I thought Haas would be higher up the hated list, the stunt he pulled last year was disgraceful. And now, we’ve gone all in on him and I just can’t see him sticking around once the Henny Pennys come knocking and they will.

Priddas was a weird one. IIRC, we were able to get him with some sort of cap extension after the reunification of the comps, (and because of the rams folding) ... but lost him because we had to get down to the new NRL salary cap within a certain period of time

 

[pennywisealfie]

BHQ Loved

32. Chris Walker

1999-2002
Position: Centre, Wing
Games: 67
Tries: 40
Highest Vote: 1 (Accept)

BHQ Loathed

32. Tevita Pangai Jr.

2016-2021
Position: Utility Forward
Games: 97
Tries: 14
Highest Vote: 3 (Mr Fourex)

 

[Xzei]

eh chris walker is best left forgotten imo didnt paint himself in the best light going at croft after one of the games when the comp restarted after covid,wonder if that is why he had to get involved with beyond blue.

 

[mitch222]

Priddis was the best 9 we’ve ever had, there I said it. He was an absolute gun, letting him go turned out to be a real error from the club.

I thought Haas would be higher up the hated list, the stunt he pulled last year was disgraceful. And now, we’ve gone all in on him and I just can’t see him sticking around once the Henny Pennys come knocking and they will.

Kerrod Walters will have your head for that comment

 

[Sproj]

Kerrod Walters will have your head for that comment

I stand by it. I also put him above S.Berrigan as a 9 but those three are the cream of the mostly average crop.

 

[Culhwch]

I stand by it. I also put him above S.Berrigan as a 9 but those three are the cream of the mostly average crop.

I'll always have a soft spot for 1998 Grand Final hero Phil Lee, and of course John Plath.

 

[Mustafur]

I stand by it. I also put him above S.Berrigan as a 9 but those three are the cream of the mostly average crop.

Over a period of time including all games for sure, but none can match what Berrigan did in the 2006 finals series.

 

[pennywisealfie]

BHQ Loved

31. Darren Smith

1995-1998, 2004-05
Position: Centre, Back Row
Games: 105
Tries: 62
Highest Vote: 8 (Culhwch)

BHQ Loathed

31. Jamayne Isaako

2017-2022
Position: Wing, Fullback
Games: 74
Tries: 24
Highest Vote: 9 (Allo)

 

[GCBRONCO]

Darren Smith one of my favourites really good both in attack and defence be it in the centres or backrow, remember seeing him play for the Bulldogs early in his career and wanting him to come to the Broncos. Got my wish!

Isucko, also got my wish! Something about that photo......

 

[Nashy]

Accurate.

 

[Mr Fourex]

Darren Smith one of my favourites really good both in attack and defence be it in the centres or backrow, remember seeing him play for the Bulldogs early in his career and wanting him to come to the Broncos. Got my wish!

Isucko, also got my wish! Something about that photo......

Both Darren and Jason Smith...excellent footballers.

 

[Mr Fourex]

Seeing Chris Walker just reminded me that I didn't like him.
Thought at times he was a bit of a fuckhead on the field.
Loose ****....

He should have been on my hated players list.....

 

[Fozz]

That photo really sums up Jamayne.