Hes not the pick for me. I also feel his career is on the downward trajectory in the next few yearaI don’t mind itA team full of lose units is no good but I like at least one bad bastard!
Hes not the pick for me. I also feel his career is on the downward trajectory in the next few yearaI don’t mind itA team full of lose units is no good but I like at least one bad bastard!
Not a fan , would much rather sua back for that aggressive roll
Where did you see this? Not questioning the legitimacy just wondering where I can go read or watch itDobby reckons Josh McGuire is coming back to brissy.
Why the only negative too him is discipline and if we are to do well it’s through discipline and there’s 3 or 4 players that will need to change with him... it’s worth it... preferably he would be captain too... I don’t think Glenn brings anything to the table in that regard Carrigan is too young and the board aren’t gonna support lodge as captain so why not bring him back... he is leader and quality consistent forward we needI hope not. Dobbo us usually wrong so that's a positive
First of all just questioning if your not a fan of McGuire... and if so I disagree I personally think if pangai stays him and Riki are a very talented and quality second row whilst I think haas and Carrigan should be our starting props for the years to come until McGuire retires and even than piakura will have hopefully emerged as the player he is growing to beNot a fan , would much rather sua back for that aggressive roll
Are you saying McGuire at lock? I’m confused.First of all just questioning if your not a fan of McGuire... and if so I disagree I personally think if pangai stays him and Riki are a very talented and quality second row whilst I think haas and Carrigan should be our starting props for the years to come until McGuire retires and even than piakura will have hopefully emerged as the player he is growing to be
Yep sorry I didn’t write that well I was talking about the pack on a whole and that McGuire can be the leader of itAre you saying McGuire at lock? I’m confused.
First of all just questioning if your not a fan of McGuire... and if so I disagree I personally think if pangai stays him and Riki are a very talented and quality second row whilst I think haas and Carrigan should be our starting props for the years to come until McGuire retires and even than piakura will have hopefully emerged as the player he is growing to be
Yes he does McGuire is only playing prop at cows because of taumalolo... personally he is a much better lock but honestly if Carrigan stayed at lock and McGuire started at Prop I couldn’t care lessPiakura is a back rower, he doesn’t play in the same position as Moose.
Obviously that’s not gonna be our side next year but I agree with you except I don’t agree with second row don’t think Su’A is a must have and Haas is a high 200 to 300 metre prop we want him at prop but the rest I quite like... whilst I think Allan would be decent I reckon his recent performances could realistically have gotten him the starting fullback spot at the rabbitohsMcGuire, Su'A, Allan, Grant, Capewell, Johnson? in
Joffa, Fifita, Bird, Turpin, Milford, Oates out
I'd say this is pretty possible. Johnson is gettable from the Sharks and I reckon he would be perfect for Dearden and likely on less than Milford. If you could dump someone else as well, don't care who and make Grant an in as well, groundwork laid for a very competitive year even next year:
1. Allan
2. Farnworth
3. Staggs (Capewell until Staggs is fit)
4. Isaako / Capewell (see who is going better once Staggs is back)
5. Coates
6. Johnson
7. Dearden
8. Lodge
9. Grant
10. Carrigan
11. Su'A
12. Haas
13. McGuire
14. Paix?
15. Flegler
16. TPJ
17. Riki
This is very doable! Get Grant in first and work your way back from there.
Yes he does McGuire is only playing prop at cows because of taumalolo... personally he is a much better lock but honestly if Carrigan stayed at lock and McGuire started at Prop I couldn’t care less
We just got the spoon and you want to sign a liability and make him captain? We already have a major discipline problem. You should join the board. He is no leader. He's a divisive grub who is on the decline.Why the only negative too him is discipline and if we are to do well it’s through discipline and there’s 3 or 4 players that will need to change with him... it’s worth it... preferably he would be captain too... I don’t think Glenn brings anything to the table in that regard Carrigan is too young and the board aren’t gonna support lodge as captain so why not bring him back... he is leader and quality consistent forward we need
Piakura plays Lock as wellNo, Moose plays prop or lock, Brendan Piakura plays edge back row. Revisit this in a couple of years and see where he will be playing. It will be edge back row.