I bleed Maroon
International Rep
- Apr 17, 2013
- 15,957
- 20,892
I'm not worried about Madden in for Mam, he will do a job for one game. Haas on the other hand is just about irreplaceable.
PRE-GAME PRE-GAME [Round 9, 2023] Broncos vs Rabbitohs
- Thread starter Kimlo
- Start date
- Status
I'm not worried about Madden in for Mam, he will do a job for one game. Haas on the other hand is just about irreplaceable.
- Aug 25, 2018
- 18,266
- 31,478
If the MRC thought Payne's tackle was borderline wouldn't they have graded him lower than Ezra? Seems like it's not worth the risk of losing him another week to me. One week is okay. I thought it would be worse.
No one seems to understand how to grade these tackles. Least of all us fans. I guess, in your argument's favour if the Broncos were to be successfully in downgrading Payne, it might set a precedent. And, accepting it would also set a precedent.
If I were to try to form an opinion on this it would that the coaches and officials have a round table on what they hope to achieve with this and determine if it's fair and even possible.
- Aug 25, 2018
- 18,266
- 31,478
I'll pick the one where we don't give up.
Let's half full this and relish the opportunity to see who's behind Ezra and Payne in the queue. I'm looking forward to it.
- Jun 13, 2019
- 10,283
- 14,810
The game needs to have a concreate ruling on this because right now this huge grey area around it still results in a sin binning from it which is a huge game changing penalty, it's unacceptable for them to not get to the bottom of it asap.
BroncosFever
State of Origin Rep
- Jun 6, 2014
- 6,224
- 11,070
The disconnect is that the bunker didn't deem it to be a hip drop however the MRC did.
The only thing that happened in that time is that the details of RCG's injury came to light. It's not a sudden shock, they usually adjudicate based on injuries. If RCG isn't hurt, no problem. Not even a penalty. We're probably the only sport in the world to punish based on injury.
The only thing that happened in that time is that the details of RCG's injury came to light. It's not a sudden shock, they usually adjudicate based on injuries. If RCG isn't hurt, no problem. Not even a penalty. We're probably the only sport in the world to punish based on injury.
- Aug 25, 2018
- 18,266
- 31,478
Seems like it's a work in progress. I'm not sure how "concrete" you can make it when it relies on a certain amount of subjectivity. Like distinguishing between intentional and careless. You can't put the judiciary in a position of needing to read the player's mind.
The judiciary is different from the ref. They have to time to deliberate and attempt to establish a standard. A referee is more subject to whim, going with the flow and is understood to make human errors - hence the appeal process.
I can certainly see an argument that Payne wasn't solely responsible for the position he was in at the completion of that tackle. The question then is: should he/could he have mitigated it? He had no control over Kobe's interaction. That's one vector.
If I were the club I would take it on the chin, but @Sproj is right that there's both a case to contest, and it's in the benefit of the competition to do so. The "early guilty plea" really sucks. Every player should have the right to please his case without being further penalized.
Otherwise, down the track fans will question why their player got two weeks and Payne only got one, and accuse the NRL of favouring the Broncos.
- Sep 19, 2012
- 7,168
- 9,095
I also noticed, that you did not answer the question as to which of the referee's decisions was the correct one.
I know you love the game, and I know you think challenging the integrity of the referees is the wrong way to go about improving the game, but many of us are of the opinion that criticism can bring improvement. However, in the current game Refs are beyond reproach. Klein made a mistake, and rather than owning up to it, he flubbed it completely. He won't face much of anything for this instance, and that is passively enabling him to continue with his poor judgements and not improve.
It could have cost the Broncos the game. It did not, but it could have. The intent is constructive criticism in the hopes of improving the game. The whole conspiracy side of things is just spice and a form of pressure towards making the league work towards eliminating these suspicions. I.e., get rid of the stink of betting agencies, honestly and critically assess referee performances instead of reactionary justifications of their errors, etc.
I think here you provide a good example of how the NRL really does need to improve. We, the fans, deserve to be better informed, and I hope the MRC provides a thorough analysis of these rulings. That way we will be able to know when our team will be fairly punished or not.
Your solution is a good one, and it is a good democratic way of solving the problem. However, as was pointed out earlier, the hip drop has been identified in the game for years now. It was issued as a memorandum at the beginning of the season, and we are now seeing a crackdown. A crackdown that is being poorly carried out in a reactionary manner and with little transparency. The NRL should have immediately requested this round table and nailed the details precisely.
The hip drop will, this season at least, be applied inconsistently, randomly, and with very little understanding overall if this continues. It will affect results, and therefore careers. For example, if Broncos lose next week, will we know it was due to Haas' absence? If Haas does challenge, will we know he was never going to win the Dally M? If a lesser-known player is suspended, will his performance that season be assessed differently due to playing less games, and will that affect potential contract negotiations?
the_next
NRL Captain
- Mar 9, 2018
- 3,120
- 6,554
If we were to somehow beat souffs without Haas and Mam, I’d say we are well into the premiership race, if we hadn’t already proved it.
I have Souffs as favourites to win the comp this year but I’d love nothing more then to see us get a win against all the odds.
My worry is that we are still such a raw side, I feel if we get pumped next week that could really hurt our chances through this tough run we have.
I have Souffs as favourites to win the comp this year but I’d love nothing more then to see us get a win against all the odds.
My worry is that we are still such a raw side, I feel if we get pumped next week that could really hurt our chances through this tough run we have.
- Aug 25, 2018
- 18,266
- 31,478
I didn't pay any attention to it.
I know how hard their job is. I know they make mistakes. I know the players cheat and lie. I know the fans get it wrong more than anyone. I know ex-players commentating are want to hyperbolize. I just go with the flow, accept whatever position gets meted out and move on. Bank errors in and against your favour are part of every sport. You can choose to get worked up in a frenzy over every instance or you can see it as inevitable.
So that's why I didn't answer. I happen to the think the refereeing in the NRL is pretty damn impressive and massively transparent. There are so many checks and balances - bunker, appeal, live slo-mos, thousands of fans watching live, press conferences explaining decisions (and occasionally admitting fault) - it's a waste of energy constructing conspiracy theories. No one is perfect.
The judiciary and MRC process, however, is not transparent. They could improve that.
- Sep 19, 2012
- 7,168
- 9,095
I guess it all depends on how you engage with the sport. For many, constructing conspiracy theories around the sport is part of the enjoyment of it. I assume in your case, contradicting them or defending the league brings you something too, otherwise you would just ignore it. Furthermore, if theories weren't being generated, then no conspiracies would be actually found, and also a number of questionable actions would simply continue and drive the league towards collapse. For example, the Storm "two books" conspiracy being proven true. For that reason, we should continue with the "Salary Sombrero" conspiracy, IMO.
I agree it is impressive, but the refs should not be beyond reproach. Klein made a mistake last night, and it should be criticised, and he should be reprimanded for it. This is part of the checks and balances of any job as you said. It remains to be seen as to whether the fallout from our match will be subject to them. Until then, the fans should be free to theorise.
- Aug 25, 2018
- 18,266
- 31,478
They are subject to reproach through their own organizational structure. While they're expected to make mistakes - they're human - some can get them demoted, suspended or even sacked. They also have their own coaches.
Lockysillegitimatechild
State of Origin Rep
- Apr 10, 2015
- 5,601
- 10,863
Good work nrl. Souffs will pull those sydney clubs closer to us now, sure Penrith and souths need the help given the last few years. And wtf is the challenge system? You get 1 more week if you fail? How fucked is that. Are they suddenly more guilty for daring to challenge the almighty nrl? What a complete mess of a corrupt system...
On the game, I hope Walters picks tapau to start, but doesn't name him till the last minute. Tell him first 15 mins of the game and the last 15 mins of the game he needs to bring his aggression. He's been great. Jensen plays the middle 50 mins, hethrington plays more minutes, and give paliaasia middle 20-30 mins. He's not great but he does do enough to hold the middle although would be tempting to bring in a bit more x factor like willison or piakura potentially.
I hope Walters puts a rocket up flegler (especially) and carrigan to say "who's gonna prove we are more than payne with this pack?!"
Madden for mam is obvious. And I hope he just runs, runs, runs like it sounds like he has in qld cup..
On the game, I hope Walters picks tapau to start, but doesn't name him till the last minute. Tell him first 15 mins of the game and the last 15 mins of the game he needs to bring his aggression. He's been great. Jensen plays the middle 50 mins, hethrington plays more minutes, and give paliaasia middle 20-30 mins. He's not great but he does do enough to hold the middle although would be tempting to bring in a bit more x factor like willison or piakura potentially.
I hope Walters puts a rocket up flegler (especially) and carrigan to say "who's gonna prove we are more than payne with this pack?!"
Madden for mam is obvious. And I hope he just runs, runs, runs like it sounds like he has in qld cup..
Lockysillegitimatechild
State of Origin Rep
- Apr 10, 2015
- 5,601
- 10,863
This needs a *
*please note, this player was playing for the wests tigers throughout this period
Donald Garner
NRL Player
- Feb 5, 2017
- 1,505
- 1,647
Nanai just did a similar tackle to haas and he went off for a HIA because the tackled player fell on him. Not a single mention of a hip drop
Willison hasn't played in nearly a month.
- Aug 25, 2018
- 18,266
- 31,478
Billy Walters record at five-eighth is 3 from 8:
Melbourne: 1 from 1
Wests: 1 from 4 (asterisk against Brisbane)
Brisbane: 1 from 3
- Status
Unread
-
The one thing Michael Maguire won’t do after dominant Broncos win- Latest: Mick_Hancock
-
-
-
-
