Hmm...would he? That's a genuine question. As
@Foordy said, they do have KNik too which I forgot but are either of them good enough / consistent enough to step up when the going gets tough and the rest of that spine is struggling?
Also, if Newcastle really, really want to keep Milf, I can see Recliffe just saying nope, he is not a dude we want to get into a bidding war over as he is a massive risk on big money.
On a side note, if I were Redcliffe, I'd be signing Berrell and running a 9/14 of Berrell and Graham.