This player or that player?

Scorchie

Scorchie

NRL Captain
Contributor
Mar 16, 2008
3,863
4,766
Think we've missed a trick here to do this tennis bracket style...
 
holdzy

holdzy

State of Origin Captain
Contributor
May 5, 2016
9,376
9,216
Think we've missed a trick here to do this tennis bracket style...

Not really interested in that.

Todd Carney. Could have been anything but pissed it all away.


Sivo or Radradra?
 
theshed

theshed

Just a Game
Aug 28, 2010
14,652
33,557
Not really interested in that.

Todd Carney. Could have been anything but pissed it all away.


Sivo or Radradra?
Radradra hands down. Sivo is useless these days.

Feleti Mateo or Krsinan Inu
 
holdzy

holdzy

State of Origin Captain
Contributor
May 5, 2016
9,376
9,216
Radradra hands down. Sivo is useless these days.

Feleti Mateo or Krsinan Inu

Sivo looked like he was going to be really good for a while there.

Mateo. Very skillful for a big guy.

James Maloney or Cliff Lyons?
 
Blindside Bronco

Blindside Bronco

Broncos Fanboy
Oct 17, 2019
900
852
Maloney. Never liked Cliff Lyons and Maloney is a cheeky bastard and fun to watch.

Adrian Lam or Ben Hunt?
 
holdzy

holdzy

State of Origin Captain
Contributor
May 5, 2016
9,376
9,216
Maloney. Never liked Cliff Lyons and Maloney is a cheeky bastard and fun to watch.

Adrian Lam or Ben Hunt?

Lam. One of my favourites growing up, Hunt 2014-15 is hard to go past though, but I shall.

Ricky Stuart or Adam Reynolds?
 
Blindside Bronco

Blindside Bronco

Broncos Fanboy
Oct 17, 2019
900
852
Lam. One of my favourites growing up, Hunt 2014-15 is hard to go past though, but I shall.

Ricky Stuart or Adam Reynolds?
Adam Reynolds.

I always have hated Ricky Stuart with a passion Sticky lil grub!!!

Brett Mullens or Anthony Minichiello?
 
B

Bongo

NRL Player
Oct 10, 2013
1,436
1,435
Adam Reynolds.

I always have hated Ricky Stuart with a passion Sticky lil grub!!!

Brett Mullens or Anthony Minichiello?
Stuart and Mullins all the way. I did not like Stuart growing up mostly because I was i the alfie camp but Stuart was excellent. Stuart and Langer a bit underrated now. So many awesome halfbacks in late 80s early 90s.
 
holdzy

holdzy

State of Origin Captain
Contributor
May 5, 2016
9,376
9,216
Stuart and Mullins all the way. I did not like Stuart growing up mostly because I was i the alfie camp but Stuart was excellent. Stuart and Langer a bit underrated now. So many awesome halfbacks in late 80s early 90s.
Ask another question after answering
 
Blindside Bronco

Blindside Bronco

Broncos Fanboy
Oct 17, 2019
900
852
Minto of course, the elegant gazelle that he is!

Blocka Roach or Martin Bella?
Blocka.
The mad man but maybe only because I watched more of him... because Bella was mad too.

Paul Harrigan or Tony Carroll?
 
Jedhead

Jedhead

State of Origin Rep
Contributor
Jan 8, 2018
6,226
12,648
Minto of course, the elegant gazelle that he is!

Blocka Roach or Martin Bella?
Bella of course. Who else considers it safe to play origin with contact lenses in. Frikkin mad man!
 
B

Bongo

NRL Player
Oct 10, 2013
1,436
1,435
Stuart and Mullins all the way. I did not like Stuart growing up mostly because I was i the alfie camp but Stuart was excellent. Stuart and Langer a bit underrated now. So many awesome halfbacks in late 80s early 90s.
Sorry, My question is Webcke or Lazarus
Ask another question after answering
 
Accept

Accept

NRL Captain
Sep 27, 2016
3,433
3,802
Blocka.
The mad man but maybe only because I watched more of him... because Bella was mad too.

Paul Harrigan or Tony Carroll?
Probably Tunza because I'm a lifelong Bronco fan and he did an admirable job doubling as Locky's minder. But Harrigan is one of the best props to ever play the game and that running feud he had with "Spud" Carroll was legendary.

Wendell Sailor or Nathan Blacklock?
 
holdzy

holdzy

State of Origin Captain
Contributor
May 5, 2016
9,376
9,216
Sorry, My question is Webcke or Lazarus

love webcke but have to go Lazo. Best front rower to play imo

Probably Tunza because I'm a lifelong Bronco fan and he did an admirable job doubling as Locky's minder. But Harrigan is one of the best props to ever play the game and that running feud he had with "Spud" Carroll was legendary.

Wendell Sailor or Nathan Blacklock?

sailor of course. Blacklock was very entertaining but Dell is arguably the best winger of all time.

dave Taylor or Carl Webb?
 
ningnangnong

ningnangnong

HACK THE PLANET!!!
Forum Staff
Mar 5, 2008
29,467
18,080
dave Taylor or Carl Webb?

Dave Taylor is by far the more talented of the two, but he is the biggest 'what if' on the planet. I'm going with Webb. He was more consistent, and you couldn't help but love him if he was on your team - a very passionate player. In fact, I'd pick Webb purely for owning Luke Bailey in Origin. Maybe I'm being harsh on DT, but he was far too hot and cold.

Chris Walker or James Roberts?
 
holdzy

holdzy

State of Origin Captain
Contributor
May 5, 2016
9,376
9,216
Chris Walker if I’m honest, but I detest the human.

Adrian Morley or Spud Carrol?

Morley. Was a loose cannon but when he was on he was fear inducing.

matt Gillett or Boyd cordner?
 

Unread

Active Now

  • Swordfish
  • Alihaider
Top
  AdBlock Message
Please consider adding BHQ to your Adblock Whitelist. We do our best to make sure it doesn't affect your experience on the website, and the funds help us pay server and software costs.