I have another view or angle. I don't believe enough people understand that a 24/25 year old man( only talking about males here ) can be a child, an overgrown teenager, an unsteady first time adult, a well adjusted age appropriate adult or an old soul in a young body.
That's exactly why I wouldn't write off Brodie Croft or Ash Taylor or anyone for that matter. I mean, look at someone like Pat Carrigan and there I see an old soul in a young body. He seems mature way beyond his years. I swear if I only had last years ISC teams and Sydney comp teams to pick from I could find a squad that could compete. If you can find the right trigger, touch the heart of anyone you can coax a level of performance from them that even they themselves would find hard to believe.
People tend to pigeon hole themselves and some lower graders stay lower graders due to false self belief. Getting told at 22 that you're never going to make it has cost hundreds of players a chance simply because they believed some shit judges, hell, even good judges.