_wwong
International Captain
- May 27, 2013
- 23,743
- 22,587
Mead and Oates on the wings just makes too much sense.. a bigger problem is left centre though. Herbie needs a stint back in isc
[Round 18, 2021] Broncos vs Tigers
- Thread starter broncos4life
- Start date
Jason Simmons
State of Origin Rep
- Apr 18, 2013
- 5,094
- 8,095
His hands still don't work...
His kicking boot seems not to be working very well either...
So I am wondering exactly what it is he brings to the team ahead of any other right winger in the squad?
He is in his 5th season of NRL, has 73 games under his belt, was picked (briefly) for international duties but is now nowhere near them, and is still good for at least 3 boneheaded plays per game...
How many times should we keep trying this guy, before someone else?
BooKhaki
NRL Captain
- Sep 16, 2020
- 3,065
- 3,990
I think he is much better suited to a wing. We could do far worse than running with Goates and Shelby on the wing in 2022.
- Oct 17, 2013
- 12,841
- 14,848
I think this game could be used as evidence to prove they're intentionally bending us over to introduce a new team. Some of those decisions were deplorable. Kennedy never lost that ball and that tackle to take Isaako out was two movements, and that's just the start of the piss poor calls we copped all day.
In saying that we have many other issues that need to be rectified this year
- Coates should never wear a Broncos jersey again
- Croft is just fucking terrible
- Farnworth is a winger. Look to pass mate, you haven't beaten the last line one on one once yet
- Flegler is the new Ofa. Smarten up or **** off idiot
- Alex Glenn gets tackled one on one by the opposition halfback numerous times every week. Harden up you cat
- Isaako should not only never take a kick off ever again, but he should never wear our jersey again.. There's absolutely no defending kicking it out on the full as often as he does
- I don't think Tesi Niu has what it takes physically to be a fullback
- Does Keenan Palasia do anything?
- TPJ needs to go or take a massive pay cut. He can't do what he's done and stay with us
- Staggs needs to stay in the centre. 2. Oates 3. Brenko 4. Staggs and 5. Herbie for 2022
- Turpin is an absolute handbrake. Every break we made he'd follow it up with a piss poor dummy half run completely negating any positive effect the previous run had. His passing is worse than Macca's ever was too. Slower, less accurate. He's not any good and we simply do not improve next year if he's passing the ball to Reynolds
We are a fullback and a hooker short if we plan on improving next year
In saying that we have many other issues that need to be rectified this year
- Coates should never wear a Broncos jersey again
- Croft is just fucking terrible
- Farnworth is a winger. Look to pass mate, you haven't beaten the last line one on one once yet
- Flegler is the new Ofa. Smarten up or **** off idiot
- Alex Glenn gets tackled one on one by the opposition halfback numerous times every week. Harden up you cat
- Isaako should not only never take a kick off ever again, but he should never wear our jersey again.. There's absolutely no defending kicking it out on the full as often as he does
- I don't think Tesi Niu has what it takes physically to be a fullback
- Does Keenan Palasia do anything?
- TPJ needs to go or take a massive pay cut. He can't do what he's done and stay with us
- Staggs needs to stay in the centre. 2. Oates 3. Brenko 4. Staggs and 5. Herbie for 2022
- Turpin is an absolute handbrake. Every break we made he'd follow it up with a piss poor dummy half run completely negating any positive effect the previous run had. His passing is worse than Macca's ever was too. Slower, less accurate. He's not any good and we simply do not improve next year if he's passing the ball to Reynolds
We are a fullback and a hooker short if we plan on improving next year
_wwong
International Captain
- May 27, 2013
- 23,743
- 22,587
Every time isaako has kicked out on the full he is just blank. Doesn’t seem to give a shit and shrugs it off. He’ll never learn.
Hoof Hearted
QCup Player
- Oct 23, 2016
- 377
- 410
What about Tass? Is he worth a shot in the centres. And mead surely he deserves another go.
Sanjit Joseph
NYC Player
- Oct 21, 2017
- 234
- 227
I genuinely think Broncos have panicked after missing out on Hynes, seems like they thought it was a done deal. All talk of spine players (other than Hodgson) has died down since losing Hynes.
- Sep 6, 2013
- 56,893
- 69,501
Yeah why not to both and maybe give Herbie that chance at fullback finally. Niu really should be dropped after some of his 'efforts'.
Xzei
State of Origin Rep
- Mar 13, 2017
- 7,029
- 10,761
Idk depends what you believe,talk out of the broncos was that he was never a possibility because he wanted to be closer to family.
Who knows?
Big Pete
International Captain
- Mar 12, 2008
- 32,225
- 26,005
He rolled the ball along the ground which constitutes a knock-on.
His leg had already brushed the sideline before the second movement.
I thought the replay showed that Maumalo had placed a hand on him with the arm carrying the ball on the ground so it should have been ruled tackle. However it was touch and go and you can live with the call.
I can't remember too many bad calls honestly. Tamou interfered with Croft as he was playing the ball but outside of that they all seemed to be fair.
Too raw. Maybe he'd be OK for a game but defensively he makes Farnworth look like Gillmeister by comparison.
- Sep 28, 2012
- 13,214
- 11,414
I keep coming back to this post, because it's happened since Glenn came back into the side, and probably before, but I haven't looked for it. Every time they send the decoy on the angle he goes for it and we're left a player or three short out wide. Croft is still garbage but the overlap has already happened and it's a formality from there.
Herbie had a bad game but we've seen him defend far better than that, which means it's either an outlier, or the problems start back infield. My money's on the latter
- Sep 28, 2012
- 13,214
- 11,414
Looks a bit like it. I noticed he sent Turps backwards a couple of times and he may have done it then too as Turps doesn’t get knocked backwards often despite his size, though at the time I did think they were just good hitups, similar to how Lodge picks out the hooker and sends them stumbling out of tackles
NSW stables
NRL Player
- May 3, 2019
- 2,637
- 7,091
100% right. The second rower is supposed to slide and protect/assist the halfback. Glenn does not do this and is always virtually standing shoulder to shoulder with the middle forwards and that is what largely fucked our left side defence.
Because glenn was not sliding or pushing from the inside, Herbie was so worried about leilua isolating croft in the line that he kept coming in to protect/assist the half. This is not excusing herbie, he played the worst game of his career today. He did not talk to oates and left him marking 3 to 4 players at a time.
Our right side defence looks a lot better which i am putting down to gamble (and absence of coates). When they are defending you can see him communicating with his team mates and pointing at the attackers. Staggs does not rush in as often anymore because of this.
Croft contributed **** all today. 2 kicks, some shit little runs, failure to send the ball wider than glenn (who has become a major ball hog) and being a major target in the defensive line. If kelly is not good to go next week, may as well get katoni in at 6 because gamble basically did the organising, ball playing and kicking himself anyway.
- Oct 7, 2017
- 3,720
- 4,852
Wayne started with virtually a Queensland side and won six straight, There was talk at the time we might go through the season undefeated. Still took him four years for the first premiership. How I would love to relive those years - they were special.
- Oct 7, 2017
- 3,720
- 4,852
Generally find when coaches talk about the 'effort' being good when the team gets beaten - so are they.
