tommy
International Rep
- Jun 5, 2015
- 12,892
- 13,707
Oh yeah I meant selected for NSW. City Country is a nothing fixture and I'm glad Qld don't entertain the idea of having one.
So Roberts not picked?? I'm VERY happy about it but are nsw selectors really that stupid not to have him under consideration?
Oh yeah I meant selected for NSW. City Country is a nothing fixture and I'm glad Qld don't entertain the idea of having one.
This post has finally made me do it
Why I don't mind the City Country game
1: Playing the game in rural areas like Tamworth, Bathurst, Dubbo, Wagga Wagga etc brings the game and first grade NRL players to towns and people who aren't able to attend NRL matches on a regular basis or barely at all.
2: It fosters links with grassroots footy there and gives attention to country football. The local Rugby League club is the heart and soul of communities in NSW in the winter just like QLD. The bush produces the best sporting talent in the country especially to Rugby League in both NSW and QLD. Artie Beetson, Darren Lockyer, Matt Bowen, Andrew Johns, Bob Fulton, Trent Barrett, Michael Cronin with many more.
3: It gives the country boys a rare chance to represent where they are from.
4: Having a rep trial can be a good thing for some potential future representative players. I know everyone in Queensland will mock me for saying that but when you have have such a stable and dominant team like the Maroons have had which is built around the best and most consistent players of our time there is no need to stress over selections. I remember those days though when QLD where picking Michael Croker at hooker, Shannon Hegarty, John Doyle and Buttegieg, dragged Ben Ikin out of a wheelchair, named Scott Sattler as a utility, played Chris Flannery at playmaker along with Daniel Wagon and rushed a broken Scott Prince into the team. I doubt QLD would've really laughed at some kind of trial back then. If the Blues had won 9 of the previous 10 series QLD would do anything to help thir chances.
There is some great talent young talent in the NSW ranks and I can't see the harm in giving them some experience in a representative environment.
It does have a place but at times just some really stupid selections and picking mediocre players for it (John Morris for example) just gives it critics more and more ammo.
It's an absolute disgrace that he and semi are playing for Aus. It's not like they're locky or cam smith: we have plenty of actual Aussies that could do an equal or better job (klemmer, Oates).
Yeah agree, not saying the culture would be diminished that badly by having a Kiwi & a Fijian, it's just awkward when they don't even sing the national anthem for Australia..
I assume the players would feel much more passionate and comfortable if all 17 players at least grew up singing the Australian national anthem.